The Sabrina Zohar Show
The Sabrina Zohar Show

219: Dating Someone Who Won't Choose You

August 11, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

When Hope Becomes a Trap

The listener's story is painfully familiar: a gym crush who pursued her for weeks, intense daily contact, then sudden distance. She later discovered he was 31, not 29—and married. He ghosted, returned with apologies, ghosted again, reappeared every few months with promises that never materialized. Over eighteen months they went on exactly one date. Yet she kept hoping he would finally choose her.

Sabrina Zohar's response is blunt: "The answer is in the question before you asked it." The pattern itself is the diagnosis.

The Slot Machine of Intermittent Reinforcement

The core mechanism driving this kind of attachment is not love—it's intermittent reinforcement. Zohar explains it through a slot machine analogy: if you won every time, you'd get bored. If you never won, you'd quit. What keeps you pulling the lever is the sometimes—the unpredictable payoff that makes your brain release dopamine in anticipation.

"When we have novelty, it creates value," Zohar says. She points to the Tickle Me Elmo craze: everyone wanted one when supply was scarce, but when they mass-produced it, "nobody wanted one and they lost billions of dollars in their valuation. Because when something everyone can have it, it's less valuable."

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (00:34) **The Harsh Reality of Dating & "Choosing Yourself"** - Sabrina opens by reframing a listener's situation: a promising second date followed by an updated Hinge profile and dropped communication.
  • 2 (03:52) **The Clickbait Trap: Why You Can't Follow Internet Dating Rules** - Sabrina uses her own relationship to challenge rigid dating advice.
  • 3 (05:00) **Listener Voicemail: The Gym Crush Who Was Married** - A listener shares a detailed story of a year-and-a-half long situationship with a man who turned out to be married.
  • 4 (09:58) **The Dopamine Reward Loop: Why You're Hooked on the Fantasy** - Sabrina breaks down the psychological mechanism keeping the listener obsessed.
  • 5 (13:32) **Rapid Fire Q&A: "How Do I Get Over Not Being Chosen?"** - Sabrina answers a rapid-fire question about the pain of rejection.
  • 6 (15:03) **Rapid Fire Q&A: Getting "Replaced" After a 4-Year Long-Distance Relationship** - Sabrina tackles a question about an avoidant partner who moved on quickly.
  • 7 (17:56) **Rapid Fire Q&A: Mixed Signals & The Danger of Hope** - Answering a question about an ex who ends things but leaves the door open.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Show Notes

Why do you keep chasing someone who only shows up halfway? Sabrina breaks down the difference between choosing yourself and waiting to be chosen, and why hope works exactly like a slot machine when you are stuck in a situationship. She reads a listener letter about falling for a married man from the gym, unpacks why ghosting and mixed signals feel so addictive, and explains how intermittent reinforcement turns a fantasy into an obsession you cannot shake.

Plus the first ever listener voice note on modern dating and dating app burnout, why early intensity says nothing about someone's intention, and a rapid fire round covering how to get over not being chosen, surviving a long distance breakup, handling core wounds and triggers that pop up out of nowhere, and what to demand when someone comes crawling back. If you are done with breadcrumbs, low effort dating, and being the one who always texts first, this one is for you.

Pre-order Sabrina's book coming out October 2026,⁠ "Why Am I Like This?"⁠

Get your free workbook and access to the companion course after pre-ordering 'Why Am I Like This?' by filling out the form at the bottom of the page at http://sabrinazohar.com/book

Take the new and improved dating quiz! sabrinazohar.com/quiz

If you’re ready to slow down, trust your instincts, and break your old dating patterns, the Healthy Relationship Foundations Course walks you through it step-by-step  ⁠HERE!⁠

If you’re serious about changing your dating patterns instead of repeating them, the Art of Going Slow course helps you unlearn urgency, regulate your nervous system, and build real connection without rushing, chasing, or abandoning yourself ⁠HERE!⁠

Get Ad free ⁠HERE!⁠ 

Watch on Spotify. Spotify subscribers get fewer ads on my video.

Want to work with Sabrina? ⁠HERE!⁠ 

Get merch for The Sabrina Zohar Show ⁠HERE!⁠ 

Don't forget to follow ⁠Sabrina⁠ and ⁠The Sabrina Zohar Show⁠ on Instagram and ⁠Sabrina ⁠on TikTok! Video now available on ⁠YOUTUBE!⁠

Chapters:

00:00 Two Dates Then They Went Cold

03:00 Why Going Slow Beats Intensity

06:00 Gym Crush Turned Out To Be Married

09:00 Why You Can't Stop Thinking About Them

12:00 Asking Why Keeps You Stuck

15:00 You Weren't Replaced, Reframe It

18:00 Core Wounds That Randomly Po

The Sabrina Zohar Show

More from this podcast

The Sabrina Zohar Show →