Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques
Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques

317. Plot Twist: The Second Story Hiding Inside Every Great Pitch

August 24, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

“We’re all salespeople at the end of the day,” says screenwriter Rhett Reese (Deadpool, Zombieland). In a reunion conversation with Stanford GSB lecturer Matt Abrahams, Reese explains that every pitch contains two stories: the obvious one about the project itself, and a subtler one in which the person you’re pitching becomes the protagonist of their own success story. Drawing on decades of experience selling multi-billion-dollar film ideas, Reese unpacks the psychology and craft behind persuasive communication, from ruthless word economy to collaboration rules that prevent creative conflict from derailing the work.

The Two-Story Pitch

Reese argues that when you walk into a pitch meeting, you’re telling two narratives simultaneously. The first is the literal story of your idea—the plot, the characters, the hook. The second is a story about the person across the table. “Everybody has their own problems and their own challenges,” Reese says. “An executive’s problem and challenge is: I've only got so much money, and I've got to spend it in ways that are beneficial to my company.” So your second story needs to position that executive as the protagonist: You have a problem. I am the solution. If you bet on me, you will succeed. This isn’t manipulation, Reese emphasizes—it’s a genuine framing that acknowledges the listener’s risk and reward. The practical implication: before a

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

Listen to Audio Summary Open in App

What you'll learn

  • 1 (01:37) **Two Stories in Every Pitch** - Rhett Reese introduces the core metaphor of the episode: every pitch contains an explicit story and a hidden, persuasive second story.
  • 2 (03:10) **The Ruthless Art of the Punchline** - Rhett reveals his precise technique for writing funny, concise dialogue, which applies directly to any form of persuasive communication.
  • 3 (09:25) **The "Whoever Cares Most Wins" Rule** - Rhett shares the foundational conflict-resolution rule he uses with his long-time writing partner, Paul Wernick.
  • 4 (11:16) **A No-Conflict System for Creative Feedback** - Rhett describes their deliberate process for giving and receiving criticism that removes ego and territoriality.
  • 5 (14:23) **The Ambiguous Promise and Peril of AI** - Rhett breaks down his conflicted 85% terrified / 15% excited stance on AI's impact on Hollywood and creative work.
  • 6 (20:43) **Escaping the Pigeonhole of Success** - Rhett explains his intentional strategy for expanding his creative brand beyond the genre he's known for.
  • 7 (23:09) **A Communicator to Admire: Sam Harris** - Rhett names Sam Harris as his ideal communicator, praising his extemporaneous clarity.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Matt Abrahams

Show Notes

“We’re all salespeople at the end of the day.”

Whether you’re pitching a movie, an idea, or yourself, persuasion is about more than the story you’re telling—it’s also about the story your audience sees for themselves. For Deadpool and Zombieland screenwriter Rhett Reese, that means keeping communication concise, compelling, and centered on what your audience needs. In this episode of Think Fast, Talk Smart, Reese joins Matt Abrahams to share lessons from screenwriting that apply far beyond Hollywood. From cutting unnecessary words to crafting pitches that make your audience the protagonist, he explores how storytelling, collaboration, and clarity can make any message more persuasive.

Takeaways:

  • Every pitch tells two stories. You’re selling the idea itself, but you’re also showing your audience how saying yes can solve their problem, reduce their risk, and lead to their success.
  • Brevity makes your message stronger. Cutting unnecessary words and choosing them carefully helps your ideas land with greater clarity, impact, and memorability.


Activity:

  • Tell the second story. Take a pitch you’re currently working on and write one sentence describing the idea you’re selling. Then write a second sentence from your audience’s perspective: “If I say yes, what becomes possible for me?” Use that second story to reshape your pitch around their success, not just your idea.

Printable Expanded Takeaways & Activities

Episode Reference Links:

Connect:

Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques

More from this podcast

 Think Fast Talk Smart: Communication Techniques →