The Good Boy Trap: How to Stop People-Pleasing in Love - Preston Smiles - #027
October 27, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readThe Good Boy Trap: How to Stop People-Pleasing in Love
Preston Smiles opens with a quote from the Gnostic Gospels of Thomas: "If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you. But if you do not bring forth what is within you, what you do not bring forth will destroy you." For Smiles, this isn't about grand life purpose—it's moment to moment. Every time he says yes to a genuine inner hit and acts on it, he's energized. Every time he says no to what's true, he's destroyed incrementally. The problem, as host Billy Garton Jr. articulates, is that most people don't know which voice is actually theirs.
The Four Layers of Outsourced Authority
Smiles argues that humans are biological, linguistic, social-historical, and quantum beings. The third layer—being social and historical beings born into beliefs and interpretations—is where the trouble starts. He walks through a devastatingly simple genealogy of disconnection: as children, you perform for mommy and daddy's love, outsourcing your power before you have the psyche to understand what's happening. Then school rings a bell and tells you when to pee, what to learn, how to learn. Then church tells you that you can't reach God except through the priest. "We have three layers before your nervous system and psyche is formed that is telling you to outsource your power," Smiles says. No wonder people hit 25 a
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of You Choose with Billy Garton Jr.
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 Timestamped Outline
- 2 (00:04) **Opening: The Gnostic Gospels Quote** - Preston Smiles is introduced and immediately reads a quote from the Gnostic Gospels of Thomas about bringing forth what is within you
- 3 (03:20) **The Four Aspects of Being Human** - Preston explains why most people can't hear their own truth
- 4 (06:56) **The Koi Fish in the Pond Metaphor** - Preston shares a psychedelic story about realizing most people only choose within their constructed limits
- 5 (11:39) **Intuition vs. Rehearsed Ways of Being** - The conversation pivots to how to distinguish real intuition from conditioned patterns
- 6 (17:26) **Two Games: Outside-In vs. Inside-Out** - Preston contrasts the egoic game of performing for approval with authentic living
- 7 (21:26) **The G-Wagon Story: Breaking Programming** - Preston shares how manifesting his dream car revealed the real point of success
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
What if the thing you’re most afraid to say out loud is the very thing that would save you?
I opened this conversation with a line from the Gospel of Thomas: “If you bring forth what is within you, what you bring forth will save you. If you do not bring forth what is within you, what you do not bring forth will destroy you.”
Preston's response was exactly what I didn't know I needed.
Preston has spent two decades as a transformational coach, speaker and author. He is a father of four, and for more than a decade he’s led The Bridge Experience alongside his wife, Alexi.
For Preston, bringing forth what’s within you isn’t only about your purpose or your mission. It’s moment to moment. It’s the first hit in your body, and whether you act on it or talk yourself out of it. Every time you override it, you erode trust within yourself.
So in this conversation we went looking for it. We talked about how we were trained from childhood to outsource our power to our parents, our teachers and our priests long before we knew we were doing it, and why intuition is almost always the first thought, not the fifth. He explained why God, to him, is like electricity, and why the real question is whether you’ve built the infrastructure for what you’re asking for. And he told me how scheduling play into every single day, right in the middle of a launch, doubled his business.
We talked about brutal honesty versus artful honesty in relationships, what actually creates safety in a woman’s body, why arguing more brought him and his wife closer, and how to hold your ground without people pleasing or running.
We went deep on money too. Why money is the spoon, not the food. Why he sent back a $30,000 payment from a client he didn’t want to coach. How writing a book called Spiritual Millionaire took him down to his last $20,000. How to pick the one thing that moves the needle and put everything else down. And why he can sit at a table with men who have far more money than him and feel like the richest one in the room.
The line that stuck with me:“When a bird lands on a tree, its faith is not in the branch. Its faith is in its wings.”
If you’re carrying something you haven’t said yet, this one is for you. Go bring it forth!
If this conversation moves something in you, let me know by liking, commenting, and subscribing to the show.
I am committed out of my mind to bringing you conversations that alter the direction of your life, leading you to a deeper sense of belonging in the context of the world.
Follow Preston: https://www.instagram.com/prestonsmiles/?hl=en
Join the Bridge Experience: https://www.thebridgemethod.org/Follow Billy: https://www.instagram.com/billygartonjr/?hl=en
Follow the Podcast: https://www.instagram.com/youchoosepodcast/
More from this podcast
You Choose with Billy Garton Jr. →