AI Summary
5 min readOn September 27, 2020, Ashley Benfield shot Blake in the face inside a Florida apartment, then followed him outside and cut his throat from ear to ear. When police arrived, they found Blake collapsed near a security guard and Ashley gone. She was arrested later that night. The case that followed turned on a single question: was this self-defense by a woman trapped in an escalating abusive relationship, or was it an execution after the threat had passed?
The Conflicting Stories
Ashley gave multiple accounts of what happened, and they did not match. In her first interview with detectives, she described a terrifying scene: Blake had bought LSD, was waving a gun around, pointed it at her sideways, and she grabbed it. "I let loose where you should I think I shot him in his face," she said. Then, she claimed, he got up, bleeding, and came at her again. "That's when I caught him," she said—meaning she stabbed him with a knife she kept in her pocket.
But the physical evidence and witness statements told a different story. Four witnesses saw Ashley walk up to Blake after he had already been shot and slice his throat while he was on his knees, trying to get help. One witness described her jumping on his back. The medical examiner would later confirm that the throat wound was the fatal injury—not the gunshot to the face.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of True Crime Stories
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (02:06) **Opening Interrogation – Ashley Describes the Shooting** - Detective Plonzinski begins questioning Ashley about the death of Blake, starting with her Miranda rights. Ashley gives a first-person account of the incident, claiming Blake was aggressive, bought LSD, and pointed a gun at her sideways before she grabbed it and shot him in the face. She also says she then stabbed him with a knife as he came at her, and that he crawled outside screaming for help.
- 2 (04:51) **Search Warrant and Attorney Arrival** - Detective Plonzinski presents a search warrant to Ashley and her attorney, emphasizing that they cannot refuse it and that obstruction is a chargeable offense.
- 3 (06:44) **Trial Testimony – The Day of the Homicide** - The scene shifts to a courtroom, where Ashley is questioned about the day of the killing, September 27, 2020, focusing on the events leading up to the fatal encounter.
- 4 (08:57) **Cross-Examination – Relationship and Motive** - The defense attorney cross-examines Ashley, focusing on inconsistencies in her narrative about her relationship with Doug and her desire for a child.
- 5 (11:02) **The Shooting and Aftermath – Detailed Demonstration** - Ashley demonstrates the shooting sequence in court, describing how Doug stood in the doorway, turned, and made fighting motions before she fired.
- 6 (16:00) **Verdict and Sentencing** - The court announces the verdict: the defendant is guilty of manslaughter. The judge sentences Ashley to 20 years in Florida State Prison followed by 10 years of probation.
- 7 (17:00) **Post-Sentencing Interrogation – The Stabbing Contradictions** - Back in interrogation, the detective confronts Ashley with witness statements that she followed Blake outside and slashed his throat, challenging her earlier account.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-podcast-2026-police-interrogations-911-calls-and-true-police-stories-podcast--5693470/support.
More from this podcast
True Crime Stories →