True Crime Stories
True Crime Stories

Girlfriend Thought He Was Cheating And Stabs Him, Wonders Why She's Going To Jail

September 23, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

"Girlfriend Thought He Was Cheating And Stabs Him, Wonders Why She's Going To Jail"

The interrogation room is quiet except for the detective reading Lindsay her Miranda rights. She's not under arrest—not yet—but she's agreed to come in and talk. She even brought video evidence from her home security cameras, eager to show the police what happened. The detective asks for her phone passcode: 242753. Then the passcode for the Night Owl security app: capital C, lowercase a, m, s—Cams. The username is SergeantShellprac, all one word. She's cooperative, almost chatty. She doesn't seem to understand that she's about to confess to stabbing her boyfriend.

The Morning Everything Unraveled

Lindsay and Justin had been together for two years, but the relationship was "on the rocks lately." She was convinced he was cheating on her. That morning, after a round of accusatory texts, Justin showed up at her house around 11 a.m. He came inside, lay down on her bed, and an argument started. He tried to leave, but Lindsay followed him outside. She admits she was "pissed off" and started screaming at him in the alley behind her house.

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (01:09) **Interrogation Begins - Miranda Rights and Phone Access** - A detective reads Lindsay her Miranda rights inside the interrogation room, then asks for the passcode to her phone to view security camera footage she claims will show what happened.
  • 2 (05:16) **Lindsay's Initial Account of the Morning** - The detective asks Lindsay to start from the beginning of the day; she becomes emotional and describes the relationship as "on the rocks" due to cheating suspicions.
  • 3 (11:07) **The Escalation at the Car - Water and Mace** - Lindsay explains the confrontation moved to the parking lot near O'Reilly's, where Justin was fixing a flat tire, and she admits to dumping water on him twice.
  • 4 (33:20) **Physical Struggle and Fall to the Ground** - Lindsay describes the fight turning physical, with Justin knocking her to the ground and taking the mace from her.
  • 5 (38:13) **The Stabbing - Pulling the Knife** - Lindsay admits to pulling a knife from the back of her car and stabbing Justin while he was leaning over her on the ground.
  • 6 (40:29) **After the Stabbing - Justin's Collapse** - Lindsay describes the moments after the stabbing, seeing Justin walk to the front of his car, sit down, and then fall over.
  • 7 (46:32) **Relationship History and Prior Violence** - The detective shifts to questioning Lindsay about the history of their relationship and any past violence.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

Girlfriend Thought He Was Cheating And Stabs Him, Wonders Why She's Going To Jail

Become a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/true-crime-podcast-2026-police-interrogations-911-calls-and-true-police-stories-podcast--5693470/support.
True Crime Stories

More from this podcast

True Crime Stories →