The Lindsay Clancy Trial, Part 2: The Commonwealth's Own Experts Push Back
September 4, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readIn the middle of the trial for Lindsay Clancy, the Massachusetts mother who killed her three young children in January 2023 before attempting suicide, the prosecution’s own expert witnesses ended up undermining the Commonwealth’s case. After the prosecution spent two weeks arguing that Clancy faked her suicide attempt and was not seriously mentally ill, every single mental health expert they called in rebuttal described her suicide attempt as "serious" and "significant." She expected to die. She tried three separate ways to kill herself: jumping from a window, cutting herself, and taking a large number of crushed pills. One expert, Dr. Kirk Heilbrun, even agreed that Clancy had adverse reactions to her psychiatric medications from October through the event in January. The trial became a battle over whether Clancy was in the grip of postpartum psychosis or whether she made a series of calculated decisions.
The Defense Case: A Woman Begging for Help
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of This Feels Criminal: A True Crime Podcast (Formerly Killer Queens)
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (02:08) **Defense Case Begins with Family Witnesses** - The defense opens their case with testimony from Lindsay's sister and mother, establishing her deteriorating mental state in the months before the killings.
- 2 (07:44) **Lindsay's Mother Testifies About Desperate Pleas for Help** - Paula Musgrove shares devastating text messages from Lindsay begging for help and revealing her fear of losing her children.
- 3 (11:59) **Prosecution Cross-Examines Lindsay's Mother Aggressively** - Jennifer Sprague twists Paula's encouraging texts to suggest Lindsay was "getting better every single day" rather than struggling.
- 4 (18:01) **Patrick's Mother Testifies, Faces Mortal Sin Question** - Sue Clancy, who referred Lindsay to perinatal care, is cross-examined about her relationship with the children and then asked about mortal sin.
- 5 (26:41) **Psychopharmacology Expert Testifies About Hypomanic Signs** - Dr. Condi testifies about possible hypomanic behaviors after Callen's birth, including excessive exercise and getting involved in a pyramid scheme.
- 6 (29:36) **Forensic Pathologist Dr. La Pasada Testifies** - The former Rhode Island Chief Medical Examiner analyzes Lindsay's injuries and suicide attempt, contradicting the prosecution's narrative.
- 7 (33:38) **Prosecution's Exercise Band Demonstration Backfires** - Sprague tries to show the bands wouldn't stay tied, but Patrick's own testimony undermines her demonstration.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
In Part 2 of our coverage of the Lindsay Clancy trial, we hear from Lindsay's family, the hospital chaplain who spent hundreds of hours with her after the deaths of her children, and Dr. Phillip Resnick—a nationally recognized forensic psychiatrist and expert on filicide who evaluated Lindsay and concluded she was not criminally responsible.
Then the Commonwealth calls three psychiatric experts of its own in rebuttal.
They ultimately agree with prosecutors on the question that matters most: Lindsay was criminally responsible. But getting there produces some of the most surprising testimony of the entire five-week trial—and at times, the Commonwealth's own experts seem to complicate the case prosecutors spent weeks building.
One exchange in particular forces a Commonwealth expert to confront the prosecution's own opening theory head-on. His answer is one of the biggest moments of the trial.
Finally, both sides make their closing arguments and give the jury two dramatically different explanations for the same evidence.
Lindsay Clancy killed her children. That has never been disputed.
After five weeks of testimony, the question the jury must finally answer is the one this entire trial has been building toward:
Was she criminally responsible when she did it?
🧵 New to This Feels Criminal? Start with The TFC Essentials—our curated collection of the episodes that best capture what this show is all about. Join our email community and get instant access: https://thisfeelscriminal.link/essentials
Hang with us:
Support Our AMAZING Partners:
- Small Town Dicks presents 'Chasing the Golden State Killer': Investigator Paul Holes joins regular hosts Yeardley Smith (The Simpsons) and twin detectives Dan and Dave Grice for a firsthand account of one of the most significant cold case investigations in American history: the Golden State Killer. Listen to the gripping 10-part series on the Small Town Dicks feed now. <
More from this podcast
This Feels Criminal: A True Crime Podcast (Formerly Killer Queens) →