The Tucker Carlson Show
The Tucker Carlson Show

Are Christians Required to Pledge Loyalty to Bibi Netanyahu? Carrie Prejean Boller & Tucker Respond.

March 14, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

Carrie Prejean Boller was appointed by President Trump to the Religious Liberty Commission in April 2025, a 12-member body tasked with hearing from Americans facing religious persecution and making policy recommendations. By August, she was being pressured to resign. By February, she was publicly removed. Her crime, as she tells Tucker Carlson in this interview, was refusing to stop posting about the suffering in Gaza and declining to affirm that anti-Zionism is anti-Semitism. The episode is a detailed account of how a commission designed to protect religious freedom became a mechanism for enforcing a specific political theology.

The Commission and the Conflict

Prejean Boller, a former Miss California who was "canceled" in 2009 for stating her belief that marriage is between one man and one woman, was appointed to the 12-member Religious Liberty Commission in April 2025. She saw it as a chance to protect the religious freedom she had been denied. The commission included figures like Bishop Robert Barron, Cardinal Timothy Dolan, and Paula White, Trump's pastor. Prejean Boller says the work was meaningful until she began posting about the suffering in Gaza. In August 2025, she received a call from a White House official warning her that her posts were being flagged as "anti-Semitic." The official specifically told her she could not talk about Zionism, because "Zionism is th

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (00:04) **Introduction and Carrie's Background** - Tucker introduces Carrie Prejean Boller, praising her honesty and bravery. She recounts being "canceled" in 2009 for stating her belief that marriage is between one man and one woman during the Miss USA pageant, and how Donald Trump supported her.
  • 2 (04:04) **Appointment to the Religious Liberty Commission** - Carrie describes being invited to serve on the Religious Liberty Commission in April 2025, shortly after converting to Catholicism.
  • 3 (09:50) **First Warning: Accused of Anti-Semitism for Social Media Posts** - In August 2025, a White House official warns Carrie that her social media posts are being flagged as "anti-Semitic."
  • 4 (16:19) **Demand for Resignation and the "Intervention" Meeting** - Carrie receives a call from the White House PPO demanding her resignation with no explanation. She refuses.
  • 5 (28:43) **The Core Theological Dispute: Zionism vs. Christianity** - Tucker presses Carrie on the theological justification for requiring Christians to support the Netanyahu government.
  • 6 (38:56) **The Anti-Semitism Hearing: Rigged and Hostile** - Carrie describes the lead-up to the February anti-Semitism hearing, where her recommended witnesses (including Jewish anti-Zionists and Palestinian Christians) were all rejected.
  • 7 (1:10:00) **Aftermath: Firing, Silence, and the Broader War** - Carrie is fired via text by Dan Patrick, then later by an email from the White House. No other commissioner defends her.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Show Notes

Does the Christian catechism require loyalty to Benjamin Netanyahu? Apparently it does, as Carrie Prejean Boller learned the hard way.


(00:00) Trump's Religious Liberty Commission (14:53) Who Is Paula White? (30:01) What Is Replacement Theology? (32:13) Was Carrie’s Ousting in Preparation for the Iran War? (43:18) Carrie's Strange Meeting With Dan Patrick and Paula White (52:01) What Happened in the Hearing? (1:17:12) Carrie's Feud With Seth Dillon


Carrie Prejean Boller has been boldly standing for truth since 2009. Almost 20 years later here she is, the same girl, still standing. More bold than ever. Unwilling to compromise her Christian beliefs for a temporal position, even one appointed by the President of the United States.

IG: @carrieprejeanboller

X: @carrieprejean1


Paid partnerships with:

VanMan: Use code TUCKER for 15% off your first order at http://vanman.shop/tucker

Charity Mobile: A pro-life company serving pro-life customers and supporting pro-life causes for 30 years. Use promo code TUCKER to get a free phone with free activation, free shipping, and a free gift with every new line of service at https://charitymobile.com/Tucker

Cozy Earth: Luxury shouldn't be out of reach. Get up to 20% off at https://cozyearth.com/TUCKER 

Defend: Enter code "Tucker" for 20% off your purchase at https://defendcellcam.com

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

The Tucker Carlson Show

More from this podcast

The Tucker Carlson Show →