The School of Greatness
The School of Greatness

What Sociopaths Really Feel | Dr. Patric Gagne

October 19, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

What Sociopaths Really Feel

Dr. Patric Gagne was diagnosed as a sociopath, earned her doctorate writing her dissertation on sociopathy, and worked as a therapist and emergency trauma counselor. She is the author of Sociopath: A Memoir. In this conversation, she explains that the public narrative about sociopathy and psychopathy is almost entirely wrong—and that the real story is more nuanced, more treatable, and far less sensational than most people assume.

The Emotional Landscape of Psychopathy

The most common misconception is that psychopaths cannot feel anything. Gagne says this is false. "Psychopaths can feel. We feel all of the inherent emotions"—happiness, sadness, surprise, disgust, the emotions everyone is born with. What psychopaths struggle with are the social emotions: empathy, compassion, remorse, guilt, shame. These are learned through modeling, usually by watching other children. But for Gagne, there were no like-minded peers. "I understood that I didn't have these complex emotional developmental skills. I could see that my sister did. I could see that the kids around me did."

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 Timestamped Navigation Outline
  • 2 (04:04) **Inherent vs. Social Emotions in Psychopathy** - Dr. Gagne explains the fundamental distinction between emotions everyone is born with and those that must be learned
  • 3 (06:36) **The Early Experience of Emotional Disconnect** - Gagne describes growing up knowing she didn't feel what others felt, and learning to lie about it
  • 4 (11:25) **Definitions: Sociopath vs. Psychopath vs. Antisocial Personality Disorder** - The clinical distinctions between these terms and their prevalence
  • 5 (14:27) **The Claustrophobia of Concealment** - Why constantly hiding one's true emotional state is exhausting and drives destructive behavior
  • 6 (18:31) **Learning Empathy Through Shared Experience** - How Gagne developed empathic capacity by connecting with other psychopaths
  • 7 (21:42) **The Fear of Becoming a Monster** - Gagne's childhood terror that she would one day wake up and want to kill someone

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

People with psychopathy still feel, just differently from everyone around them.

Dr. Patric Gagne, a diagnosed sociopath who went on to earn a doctorate and work as a therapist, sat down with Lewis and told the story she tells in Sociopath: A Memoir. As a kid she learned that saying “I don't care” out loud got her in trouble, so she lied, and lying made her feel safe.

She talks about the pressure she called a vice, which she relieved by breaking into homes just to sit in the quiet, and the first grade day she stabbed a classmate with a pencil. Then she explains why secondary psychopathy, which may touch 5% of people, is treatable when kids get caught early.

You will hear why a therapist who doesn't absorb your pain can be the best container for it, and why stopping someone from crying can stop the brain from healing. She also gets into the shame under people pleasing and narcissism, and the question she asks her own kids: how does it feel when you feel?

You may come away a little gentler with the people you never understood, and with the kid you used to be.

Sociopath: A Memoir

Dr. Patric's Instagram

Dr. Patric's Website

The Society for the Prevention of Disorders of Aggression

In this episode you will:

  • Become a calm container for someone's pain without needing to empathize
  • Raise emotionally aware kids through boundaries, apologies and positive reinforcement instead of punishment
  • Learn why awareness is 80% of the work in changing destructive patterns
  • Discover why psychopaths can feel emotion and what actually separates them from everyone else
  • Spot the warning signs of sociopathy in dating, relationships and business partnerships
  • Break free from people pleasing by choosing honesty over curated, falsified emotions

For more information go to https://lewishowes.com/1995

More SOG episodes we think you’ll love!

Get More From Lewis!


Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

The School of Greatness

More from this podcast

The School of Greatness →