AI Summary
5 min readThe Harmony Montgomery Case: Conviction Overturned
In December 2019, five-year-old Harmony Montgomery was beaten to death by her father Adam after she had a potty accident while the family was living in a car in New Hampshire. He punched her, felt something break inside her, pulled over, and found she was dead. He then put her body in the trunk, moved it to the ceiling vent of a homeless shelter, stored it in a walk-in freezer at the restaurant where he worked, and eventually thawed her out in a bathtub, bought tools, and dismembered her. Her body has never been found. Adam Montgomery was convicted of her murder in 2024 and sentenced to 45 years to life. But in a decision that shocked many, the New Hampshire Supreme Court overturned that murder conviction. He remains in prison on other charges—43 and a half years for related crimes—but the murder conviction itself is gone.
The Defense Strategy That Worked
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of The Prosecutors
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:35) **Case Overview: The Murder of Harmony Montgomery** - Alice and Brett introduce the case of five-year-old Harmony Montgomery, murdered by her father Adam Montgomery, and explain that his murder conviction was overturned by the New Hampshire Supreme Court.
- 2 (03:10) **The Facts of the Crime** - Brett recounts the timeline of abuse and murder, from the July 2019 assault to the December 2019 killing and the subsequent disposal of Harmony's body.
- 3 (07:54) **The Good News: Other Convictions Stand** - Alice clarifies that while the murder conviction was overturned, other related charges remain, keeping Montgomery in prison for 43.5 years.
- 4 (09:18) **The Legal Issue: Joinder of Charges** - Brett explains the core procedural error: the trial court improperly joined the second-degree assault charge (from July 2019) with the second-degree murder charge (from December 2019).
- 5 (12:54) **New Hampshire Rule 20 and the "Best Interest of Justice" Standard** - Brett details the specific legal rule and the four-factor test the court used to determine that severance was required.
- 6 (16:28) **The State's Argument and the Court's Reasoning** - The hosts walk through the prosecution's counter-argument and why the Supreme Court rejected it.
- 7 (19:10) **The Weakness of the Murder Case** - Brett explains why the murder charge was more vulnerable: the only direct witness was Kayla Montgomery, who had credibility issues and a motive to lie.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
We discuss the disappointing result out of New Hampshire, where the state's Supreme Court has overturned the conviction of Adam Montgomery in the brutal murder of his daughter, Harmony, on dubious grounds. What does it mean? And what's next?
Check out more about the cases we cover on The Prosecutors + at our Substack the True Crime Times
Check out our other show, The Prosecutors, for true crime cases and mysteries.
For early and ad-free access to episodes as well as the opportunity to watch us record episodes live, join our Patreon
For early and ad-free episodes, you can subscribe on Apple Podcasts.
Join our fan-run Facebook Group: the Gallery on Facebook for case discussions, hot legal topics, and more.
Follow us on X or as we’ll always call it: Twitter @prosecutorspod
Find us on Instagram or Threads @prosecutorspod
Check out our website for case resources
Hang out with us on TikTok @prosecutorspod
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
More from this podcast
The Prosecutors →