1409: Lindsay Owens | How Your Own Data Is Used to Overcharge You
November 5, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readIn December 1924, the CEOs of the world's major light bulb manufacturers met in a snowy Geneva hotel room and agreed to make their product worse. They called themselves the Phoebus Cartel—Phoebus being the god of light—and their plan was simple: throttle the lifespan of the light bulb from thousands of hours down to about half that. They even set up a testing lab in Germany where each company had to send samples to prove they weren't secretly making bulbs that lasted too long. Why? Because a bulb that burns for a hundred years, like the one still glowing in a Livermore, California firehouse today, is a commercial disaster: once every household buys five, they never need another one.
That story opens economist Lindsay Owens's argument that corporate America has reinvented the ripoff. The old model required CEOs to lock arms in a smoke-filled room and risk prosecution. The new model lets them coordinate pricing from their couches through algorithms, using your own data to determine exactly how much you will pay—and then charging you that amount.
The dawn raid and the algorithm that hates empty units
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of The Jordan Harbinger Show
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (02:41) **The Vanishing Public Price** - Jordan introduces the episode’s central mystery: personalized pricing sounds like a deal but often means you get overcharged, and Lindsay Owens explains how the system works.
- 2 (03:10) **The FBI Raid on Cortland Management** - The government investigates a landlord for using a pricing algorithm to coordinate rent hikes, revealing a modern price-fixing scheme.
- 3 (03:51) **How RealPage’s Algorithm Rigged the Market** - The software’s specifications were engineered to hose renters, with a hard floor on prices and a soft ceiling, leaving units empty rather than lowering them.
- 4 (09:13) **Why Software-Based Coordination Is Still Collusion** - Lindsay explains that when software facilitates the sharing of competitively sensitive information and aligns prices, it enters territory seen as collusion, regardless of the technology used.
- 5 (11:04) **The Extinction of the Price Tag** - Lindsay argues that the public, stable, knowable price is disappearing, replaced by dynamic pricing based on algorithmic factors, and traces the history of the price tag from John Wanamaker.
- 6 (14:29) **The Instacart Experiment: 75% of Items Vary in Price** - Lindsay and her organization recruited over 400 people to shop the same 23-item basket at the same time on Instacart, finding massive price variation between shoppers.
- 7 (18:12) **Instacart’s Response and the Lab’s Closure** - After public backlash and pressure from the Trump administration and state attorneys general, Instacart shut down the pricing experiments, but the story has a twist.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
Gouged author Lindsay Owens explains how corporate America reinvented the ripoff with algorithms and surveillance pricing, and how shoppers can fight back.
Full show notes and resources can be found here: jordanharbinger.com/1409
What We Discuss with Lindsay Owens:
- How price-fixing went digital. RealPage software allegedly let landlords share sensitive data and follow the same rent recommendations, complete with a hard price floor, a soft ceiling, and advice to leave units empty rather than offer discounts.
- What happened when 400+ shoppers filled identical 23-item Instacart carts at the same stores. 75% of items varied in price from person to person, by as much as 23%, and the average 7% gap costs a family of four roughly $1,200 a year.
- Why surveillance pricing, which taps your location, device, purchase history, clicks, and even what you confess to AI shopping agents, doesn’t just soak the rich — it monetizes urgency, like a sick kid, a funeral flight, or a last-minute prom dress.
- How repair locks on everything from McFlurry machines to John Deere tractors create a daisy chain of price gouging on purchases, parts, labor, and replacements — and why threatening to void your warranty over third-party repair is illegal.
- How to fight back by turning the experiment around: compare prices logged in vs. out, in the app vs. on the website vs. in store, and with or without loyalty cards. Have friends check the same fare, limit tracking, and speak up — backlash made Coke and Instacart retreat.
- And much more...
And if you're still game to support us, please leave a review here — even one sentence helps!
- Sign up for Six-Minute Networking — our free networking and relationship development mini course — at jordanharbinger.com/course!
- Subscribe to our once-a-week Wee Bit Wiser newsletter today and start filling your Wednesdays with wisdom!
- Do you even Reddit, bro?
More from this podcast
The Jordan Harbinger Show →