The Jordan Harbinger Show
The Jordan Harbinger Show

1385: Food Deserts | Skeptical Sunday

September 20, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

The Billion-Dollar Food Desert Mistake

For decades, the logic seemed unassailable: if a neighborhood lacks a grocery store, people will eat worse, so build them a grocery store. The Obama administration poured roughly a billion dollars into this idea through the Healthy Food Financing Initiative, aiming to eliminate "food deserts" within seven years. Thousands of new supermarkets opened across the country. There was just one problem: it barely changed what people ate.

Where the Food Desert Idea Came From

The term "food desert" originated in early 1990s Britain, where researchers noticed low-income neighborhoods lacked supermarkets and relied on convenience stores and takeaways. The logic was intuitive—if healthy food is far away and junk food is close, people eat worse. When the concept crossed the Atlantic, the USDA formalized it: a food desert is a low-income census tract where at least 500 people or 33% of the population live more than a mile from a large grocery store. About 20 million Americans—roughly 6% of the population—live in areas meeting both the low-income and low-access criteria.

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 Skeptical Sunday: Food Deserts
  • 2 (01:40) **Episode Introduction** - Jordan Harbinger and Jessica Wynne introduce the topic: food deserts and why the common-sense solution of building grocery stores isn't working.
  • 3 (03:16) **What Is a Food Desert?** - Jessica defines the term, coined in the 1990s in the UK for low-income neighborhoods lacking convenient access to affordable healthy food.
  • 4 (07:27) **Billions Spent, Seven-Year Deadline** - The federal response to food deserts and the scale of investment.
  • 5 (08:41) **The Surprising Finding: It Didn't Work** - Researchers measured diet changes after grocery stores opened and found almost nothing.
  • 6 (12:13) **Real-World Case Studies: Philadelphia, New York, Pittsburgh** - Researchers tracked actual supermarket openings in food deserts.
  • 7 (15:10) **The Pittsburgh Store Closed** - The subsidized supermarket shut down in 2019 because not enough people shopped there to keep it viable.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

The map says oasis; the aisles say Doritos. This Skeptical Sunday, Jessica Wynn explains why grocery stores failed to fix how low-income neighborhoods eat.

Welcome to Skeptical Sunday, a special edition of The Jordan Harbinger Show where Jordan and a guest break down a topic that you may have never thought about, open things up, and debunk common misconceptions. This time around, we’re joined by writer and researcher Jessica Wynn!

Full show notes and resources can be found here: jordanharbinger.com/1385

On This Week's Skeptical Sunday:

  • A 'food desert' is the USDA's label for a low-income neighborhood where hundreds of people live over a mile from a large grocery store — too far, the theory goes, so they eat worse. Build a store and diets improve. Yet billions of dollars later, most residents were already driving past one to shop elsewhere.
  • Distance was never the driver — equalizing access and prices closes just nine to ten percent of the diet gap. The rest is preference, and preference isn't fixed taste; it's learned from culture, marketing, price, and stress. West Harlem got a great supermarket 15 years ago, yet obesity stayed high.
  • The same government building stores to fix diets spends roughly $9 billion a year subsidizing crops like corn and soy — the raw material for syrup, seed oils, and cheap meat. Fresh produce gets under ten percent. No wonder a pint of blueberries costs more than a family-size bag of Blue Takis.
  • The sharper problem isn't the desert but the swamp — neighborhoods saturated with fast food, dollar stores, and junk promotions. Counties with the worst swamp scores saw 77% higher obesity-related cancer deaths. A store can even be a mirage: it's there, but the shelves are mostly Doritos.
  • You can't buy health by proximity, but you can build it through knowledge. Don't abandon the food you love; adjust it. Swap corn oil for olive, tweak a method, make one familiar dish a little healthier. Preference is learned, which means it can be relearned, starting now.
  • Connect with Jordan on Twitter, Instagram, and YouTube. If you have something you'd like us to tackle here on Skeptical Sunday, drop Jordan a line at The Jordan Harbinger Show