Founder of Kit Reveals How to Make 7 Figures Off a Small Email List
October 13, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readThe $1-Per-Subscriber Rule That Changes Everything
Nathan Barry, founder of the email marketing platform Kit, has access to data from over 100,000 creator businesses. What he sees consistently is that the most profitable creators hit a specific metric: one dollar per email subscriber per month. A creator with 3,000 subscribers can clear over a million dollars a year. A creator with 50,000 subscribers can hit $2 to $3 per subscriber per month. The difference isn't list size—it's what they do with the list.
The Two Non-Negotiables for High Revenue Per Subscriber
Barry is direct about what separates the top earners from everyone else. First, you have to be selling your own products. Creators who rely primarily on brand deals and advertising sponsorships simply cannot hit the $1-per-subscriber benchmark because the CPM math doesn't work. The people who do hit it are selling digital products—courses, coaching, memberships, software—with clear upsells and cross-sells built in.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of the bossbabe podcast
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (01:01) **The $1 Per Subscriber Per Month Rule** - Nathan Barry claims creators should earn at least $1 per email subscriber per month and backs it with Kit's internal data on 100,000+ creator businesses.
- 2 (04:00) **Kit's Behind-the-Scenes Data & Email Cadence Advice** - Nathan describes what Kit tracks and shares his philosophy on how often to email your list.
- 3 (10:08) **Email Metrics That Actually Matter** - Nathan advises against comparing open rates to industry averages and explains what to watch instead.
- 4 (12:08) **The New Rules of List Cleaning & Subscriber Signals** - Nathan explains why list cleaning is more important than ever and how Kit's new feature turns it into an opportunity.
- 5 (14:45) **How Finding Gretchen Rubin on His List Changed Everything** - Nathan shares a real story of discovering a famous author in his subscriber list and the relationship it created.
- 6 (20:10) **Practical List Cleaning Cadence & High-Ticket Segmentation** - Nathan gives specific timing for removing cold subscribers and how to identify your most valuable ones.
- 7 (23:38) **Migrating to Kit & The Revenue Tracking Integration** - Nathan confirms that Kit imports historical revenue data from platforms like Kajabi, solving a common pain point for creators.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
If you think your email list is too small to monetize or convert, today's guest will prove you wrong.
In this episode, founder of Kit Nathan Barry reveals the secrets behind million-dollar email lists. He breaks down how to clean your email list, what to sell in your newsletters, and how to target high-value subscribers to convert. He also walks through his process for building flywheels that compound newsletter growth and revenue over time.
In this episode, Natalie and Nathan discuss:
(01:02) Why Every Email List Should Make $1 Per Subscriber
(05:34) The Best Cadence for Sending Emails
(13:42) The Right Way to Clean Your Email List in 2026
(21:57) How Kit Enables You to Identify High-Value Subscribers
(24:48) Creating Low-Friction, High-Conversion Flywheels
(30:20) The 30-Day Test for Growing Your Email List From Nothing
(38:06) Is AI Killing Lead Magnets?
(43:19) What the Most Profitable Email Lists Are Doing
(50:02) Why a Big Audience Isn't Always Beneficial
(55:29) Big List, Low Revenue? Fix This
(1:03:46) How to Learn the Skill of Making Money
Nathan Barry is a creator, author, speaker, designer, and the founder of Kit, an email marketing platform built for creators. He began as a designer and author, using self-published books and email marketing to generate creator income before building Kit as a broader platform for creator businesses. He advocates audience ownership, teaching what you know, sustainable monetization, and building products rather than relying only on personal brand attention.
Sponsored By:
FreshBooks - Get FreshBooks for less than $3 a month for your first four months at FreshBooks.com/podcast.
Faire - Sign up today and get 50% off your first wholesale order, up to $100 at faire.com/bossbabe.
AG1 - Save 20% on your first subscription order of AG1 Next Gen or AG1 Pro at drinkAG1.com/bossbabe.
Hostinger - Go to Hostinger.com/bossbabe and use code BOSSBABE for 10% off.
Resources Mentioned:
More from this podcast
the bossbabe podcast →