It Was the Best of Times, It Was the Worst of Times (with ‘Trust’ Author Hernan Diaz)
November 15, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readIt Was the Best of Times, It Was the Worst of Times (with ‘Trust’ Author Hernan Diaz)
Hernan Diaz doesn't think we're living in a dystopia. He thinks we're living in a cultural narcissism problem. "I don't know when this occurred," he says, "that we as a species, or as a culture rather, became enamored with our own demise and found this sort of giddiness in our own extinction." He calls it "the world ends with me" thinking: "I am here as the last witness and I'm going to turn out the light, shut the door, and leave." His new novel Ply has been called dystopian, but Diaz rejects the label entirely. He's not writing about collapse. He's writing about what might hatch through the cracks.
The World of Ply and Why It Isn't Dystopian
Ply is set centuries from now in New York City, after the United States has dissolved into a collection of city-states. The protagonist is a teenage girl known only as "the pincher" — someone who steals electricity from the grid and sells it on the black market. She's an orphan, and the novel follows the family she forms with an older woman and a younger girl, the trust that emerges among them and the betrayals they endure.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Talk Easy with Sam Fragoso
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:00) **Opening: Cultural Narcissism & The Giddiness of Doom** - Diaz critiques our culture's fascination with apocalypse, calling it a form of vanity where we believe the world ends with us.
- 2 (01:11) **Introduction to the Guest & His New Novel, *Ply*** - Sam introduces Hernan Diaz, his Pulitzer win for *Trust*, and the premise of his new book set centuries in the future.
- 3 (02:44) **Hollywood, Control, and Letting Go** - Diaz discusses the slow-moving adaptation of *Trust* with Todd Haynes and Kate Winslet, revealing his struggle to release control of the project.
- 4 (04:47) **The World of *Ply*: The End of Modernity** - Diaz describes the novel’s setting as a world where modernity has ended and a new order is emerging, focusing on a found family of three women.
- 5 (08:15) **The State as a Second Nature** - Diaz argues that the modern state is a recent invention, not a permanent fixture, and that we must imagine new forms of sociability beyond it.
- 6 (12:32) **Reading: The End of the Renaissance** - Diaz reads a passage from *Ply* where the character Acevedo outlines a historical shift from a human-centered world to one where the human itself has been displaced.
- 7 (14:58) **Against Dystopia and Utopia** - Diaz explains his dislike for both the terms "dystopia" and "utopia," finding them either narcissistic or saccharine.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
It was the best of times, it was the worst of times.
This fall, Pulitzer Prize-winning novelist Hernan Diaz (Trust, In the Distance) released Ply, a sweeping, Dickensian story set centuries in the future, long after the United States has ceased to exist.
We begin with the world of the new book (3:00), why Diaz rejects the idea that it’s a dystopian story (14:00), and how he achieves his fluid authorial voice (22:00). Then, he describes his childhood in exile following Argentina’s 1976 military coup (25:50), the influence of his parents on his writing life (28:05), and his winding path to becoming a novelist (33:00).
On the back-half, Diaz shares how we weathered the years of rejection that preceded his first novel In the Distance (39:00), the through line across his books (45:00), the scientific ideas that inspired Ply (58:00), and why, in an age of technological upheaval, Diaz believes fiction can bring us closer to one another (1:04:00).
Subscribe to our YouTube channel.
As always, our email: [email protected].
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
More from this podcast
Talk Easy with Sam Fragoso →