AI Summary
5 min readIn April 1935, a 12-foot tiger shark was caught off Coogee Beach near Sydney, Australia. The fisherman who caught it realized the shark could be a profitable attraction—three men had been killed by sharks on New South Wales beaches in the preceding weeks, and the public was both terrified and fascinated. The shark was placed in a tank at a local aquarium, where it swam around with a bad attitude, flipping off the spectators. Then, on Anzac Day, the shark started acting strangely: lethargic, sluggish, disoriented. And then it vomited up a human arm.
The Arm That Didn't Come from a Shark
At first, everyone assumed the arm belonged to another unlucky swimmer. But when pathologists examined it, they realized the arm had been cleanly cut off—not bitten. It was also remarkably well preserved. The arm bore a distinctive tattoo of two boxers squaring off. The police published a description, and a man named Edwin Smith came forward: the tattoo matched his brother Jim's, who had been missing for weeks. Fingerprints confirmed it. The rest of Jim Smith's body was never found.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Stuff You Should Know
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:02) **Episode Intro & Shark Capture** - Josh and Chuck introduce the infamous 1935 "Shark Arm Murder" case from Sydney, Australia.
- 2 (02:56) **The Shark Vomits a Human Arm** - On Anzac Day, the shark began acting lethargic before regurgitating a human arm in front of horrified onlookers.
- 3 (05:02) **The Victim: Jim Smith** - A man named Edwin Smith identified the arm as belonging to his missing brother, Jim Smith, and fingerprints confirmed the identity.
- 4 (06:58) **The Prime Suspects Emerge** - Investigators traced Jim Smith's last known movements to a hotel where he was drinking with his friend, Patrick Brady, a known forger.
- 5 (10:42) **The Insurance Scam & Motive** - The connection between Smith and Holmes was a falling out over a criminal insurance scam, with Smith allegedly blackmailing Holmes.
- 6 (12:12) **The Case Stalls and a Suspect's Suicide Attempt** - With only circumstantial evidence, police arrested both Brady and Holmes, but neither confessed.
- 7 (13:26) **Holmes Turns Witness, Then is Murdered** - After his arrest, Holmes agreed to testify against Patrick Brady as the actual killer.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
Get yer info on one of Australia’s great true crime cases he-re!
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
More from this podcast
Stuff You Should Know →