AI Summary
5 min readIn 2019, a former missing persons detective sat down to recount the case that ended his career. He had joined the force at 21, drawn to missing persons work because it felt morally pure—"unfaultable work," he called it. For years, he found deep fulfillment in returning children to their families. But one case changed everything. Five children, ages four to six, vanished from the same suburban neighborhood on the same day. The detective treated it as a serial kidnapping, and his team quickly found security camera footage. What it showed was unlike anything they had ever seen.
The Piper Emerges
The footage, taken from the back of a supermarket, showed a tall man in a bizarre costume walking through an alley. He wore a Mr. Punch mask—pale white with crimson cheeks, bulging eyes, and a hooked nose—along with a jester's cap and bells, a long patchwork coat with dozens of pockets, and pointed shoes that curled upward. From each hip hung a black-and-white diamond handkerchief that stretched several meters behind him. The five children gripped the fabric with both hands, skipping happily as if in a trance. The man played a wooden pipe, repeating the same tune over and over: "Greensleeves." The detective described the melody as "utterly entrancing" but also "nothing but terrifying." The procession moved through the alley and out of frame. The press soon dubbed the kidnapper "the P
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Scary Stories
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (02:03) **A Detective’s Introduction and the Case That Broke Him** - The narrator establishes his background as a passionate missing persons detective and sets up the five-child disappearance that ended his career.
- 2 (04:06) **The Disappearances and Initial Investigation** - The detective learns of five children, ages four to six, who vanished from the same neighborhood on the same day.
- 3 (06:32) **The First Footage: The Piper Appears** - The detective and his team watch security camera footage that reveals a bizarre and terrifying kidnapper, not a typical predator.
- 4 (15:55) **The Search Widens and the Nickname Sticks** - Despite a city-wide search and a press conference, no sightings emerge, and the media dubs the kidnapper “The Piper.”
- 5 (17:45) **Second Footage: The Deterioration** - The detective and his partner, Jeffords, view new security footage showing the children have become gaunt and are being pulled along, while the Piper performs a chilling ritual with rats.
- 6 (21:42) **The Case Goes Cold** - The investigation hits a dead end, and the detective is haunted by the footage, unable to move on.
- 7 (23:28) **A New Lead: The Rat Migration** - Three months later, the detective overhears a conversation about a massive, freak rat migration upstate, which he connects to the Piper.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
I used to be a missing person detective, this is the creepiest case I ever worked
Advertising Inquiries: https://redcircle.com/brands
Privacy & Opt-Out: https://redcircle.com/privacy
More from this podcast
Scary Stories →