Ep 1391 | 3 Reasons Lindsay Clancy Is Absolutely Guilty
September 2, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readThe Case for Criminal Responsibility in the Lindsay Clancy Trial
The jury had been deadlocked for 18 hours when the judge sent them back to keep deliberating. That deadlock itself was already a victory for the defense—the idea that a jury could even debate whether a woman who admitted to strangling her three children one by one with exercise bands was criminally responsible. As the trial unfolded, the central question became not whether Lindsay Clancy killed Cora, Dawson, and Callan, but whether her mental illness rendered her legally incapable of knowing right from wrong at the time.
Mental Illness Is Not Legal Insanity
The prosecution made a crucial distinction that the defense's case depended on blurring: being mentally ill is not the same as being legally insane. Nearly everyone in the trial agreed that Clancy was struggling. Prosecutor Jennifer Sprague said in closing, "There's no dispute that Lindsay Clancy was suffering from mental illness and that she tried to kill herself. That's not the issue in this trial. The issue is whether at the time she killed Cora, Dawson, and Callan, she knew the difference between right and wrong, and whether she could conform her behavior to the requirements of the law."
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:00) **Empathy-Based Justice is Not Justice** - Allie introduces the core moral problem: judging based on personal feelings toward the defendant rather than the facts.
- 2 (01:40) **God's Sovereignty and Earthly Justice** - Allie grounds the discussion in biblical principles of judgment and the purpose of government.
- 3 (05:09) **Trial Status and Jury Deadlock** - Updates on the jury's inability to reach a unanimous verdict after extensive deliberation.
- 4 (07:13) **Prosecution vs. Defense Arguments** - Summarizes the core legal dispute: planning and responsibility versus postpartum psychosis.
- 5 (09:26) **The Defense Attorney's Rhetoric** - Critiques the defense's characterization of Clancy as a "darn good mother."
- 6 (12:57) **Gender and the Jury Composition** - Analyzes the disproportionate online support for Clancy from women and its implications for impartiality.
- 7 (15:18) **Biblical Call to Impartial Judgment** - Argues that Christians must set aside personal feelings and judge objectively based on facts.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
The jury in the Lindsay Clancy remains deadlocked. Allie explains the possible verdicts available to the jury and presents three concise reasons why Clancy should be convicted of the willful murder of her children. If the jury is unable to decide on a verdict, the judge will declare a mistrial and the prosecutors will decide whether to retry the case. Many women, both liberal and conservative, have sided with Clancy. Allie warns against losing sight of the actual victims in this case and challenges them to think about how they would react if the victims had been their own children. Justice should never be rooted in compassion but in truth. Empathy-based justice is not justice at all. Every piece of evidence and information in the case should be viewed in light of the undisputed fact that Lindsay Clancy murdered her three kids. Even in the midst of this darkness and confusion, Allie reminds Christians that God’s plan of redemption is going off without a hitch; he is completely sovereign, even over something as awful as this. Allie concludes the episode by looking at “Oreo gate” — the viral social media mom drama concerning Oreos in school lunches — and whether it is even real.
Do you have a question for Allie? Leave a voicemail at 844-755-5252
Share the Arrows 2026 is on October 10 in Dallas, Texas! Tickets are on sale now at: https://sharethearrows.com
Share the Arrows is sponsored by:
A'del Natural Cosmetics: AdelNaturalCosmetics.com
Range Leather: RangeLeather.com/ALLIE
We Heart Nutrition: WeHeartNutrition.com
Buy Allie's book "Toxic Empathy: How Progressives Exploit Christian Compassion": https://www.toxicempathy.com
–
Time Codes
00:00 - Opening
04:56 - Closing Arguments & Verdict Updates
12:44 - A Closer Look at the Jury and the Punishment Options
27:22 - Reason #1 She Should Be Found Guilty: Mental Illness Is Not the Same as Legal Insanity
39:09 - Reason #2 She Should Be Found Guilty: The Evidence Shows She Planned the Murders
50:49 - Reason #3 She Should Be Found Guilty: She Was Only Diagnosed with Psychosis After the Murders
1:02:07 - Tyler Robinson Trial Reminder
1:03:07 - Oreogate
–
Today's Sponsors:
Seven Weeks Coffee | Experience the best coffee while supporting the pro-life movement with Seven Weeks Coffee; use code ALLIE at https://www.sevenweekscoffee.com to get up to 25% off your first order, plus your free gift!
We Heart Nutrition | Check out We Heart Nutrition at WeHeartNutrition.com and use the code ALLIE for 20% off.
Take charge of your health expenses and be part of a community. Join CrowdHealth to get started today for $99 a month for
More from this podcast
Relatable with Allie Beth Stuckey →