AI Summary
5 min readThe Future of the American Right: Why a Third Party Is a Mistake
Scott Horton joins Dave Smith to argue against the emerging push—from figures like Michael Heise and Brett Weinstein—to rebrand the Libertarian Party as an "America First Party" and recruit high-profile anti-war figures like Thomas Massie, Tucker Carlson, and Joe Kent to run under that banner. Horton and Smith believe this strategy would be catastrophic for the anti-war movement, handing the country back to Democrats while abandoning the most promising battlefield: the Republican Party itself.
The Opening That the Iran War Created
The conversation begins with the 2026 election results, which both hosts see as a direct repudiation of Donald Trump's Iran war. Smith notes that the war "destroyed the Trump coalition" in a way that even the president and vice president have acknowledged. Voters who had been promised no new wars saw one launched anyway, and they either stayed home or voted Democrat to send a message. The result was a historic loss for Republicans.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Part Of The Problem
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:00) **Healthcare Fraud PSA** - A public service announcement about recognizing and reporting healthcare fraud.
- 2 (00:36) **Intro & Setting the Table** - Host Dave Smith welcomes Scott Horton and introduces the topic: the future of the American right after the 2026 election.
- 3 (02:35) **The Constitution & The War** - Scott Horton argues the war is criminal because the Constitution gives Congress, not the President, the power to declare war.
- 4 (13:34) **The Landscape on the Right** - Horton describes the American right as deeply split, with a massive, fertile ground for a truly non-interventionist candidate.
- 5 (19:10) **The Third Party Argument** - Horton lays out his case against a third party move, beginning with a disclaimer that he loves the Mises Caucus people but strongly disagrees with this strategy.
- 6 (25:00) **The Pat Buchanan Precedent** - Horton uses the story of Roger Stone tricking Pat Buchanan into a third-party run as a cautionary tale of how to destroy a non-interventionist Republican.
- 7 (41:51) **The Ron Paul Example** - Horton and Smith argue that Ron Paul's success came from running as a Republican, not a Libertarian, and that the current moment is even more favorable.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
Dave Smith brings you the latest in politics! On this episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave and Scott Horton discuss Thomas Massie's articles of impeachment against Pete Hegseth being shut down, the future of the American right, the role that Libertarians play, and more.
Support Our Sponsors:
BodyBrain - Go to BodyBrainCoffee.com, use code DAVE20 for 20% off your first order.
Superpower - Head to Superpower.com and use code PROBLEM at checkout for $20 off your membership. Unlock your new health intelligence. 100+ biomarkers. Every year. Detect early signs of 1,000+ conditions. #superpowerpod
Part Of The Problem is available for early pre-release at https://partoftheproblem.com as well as an exclusive episode on Thursday!
PORCH TOUR DATES HERE:
https://www.porchtour.com
Find Run Your Mouth here:
YouTube - http://youtube.com/@RunYourMouth
iTunes - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-your-mouth-podcast/id1211469807
Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/4ka50RAKTxFTxbtyPP8AHm
Follow the show on social media:
X:
http://x.com/ComicDaveSmith
http://x.com/RobbieTheFire
Instagram:
http://instagram.com/theproblemdavesmith
http://instagram.com/robbiethefire
#libertarian
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
More from this podcast
Part Of The Problem →