Part Of The Problem
Part Of The Problem

Mamdani Defines Socialism

October 6, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

Eric Adams, the mayor of New York City, went on Theo Von's podcast and was asked a simple question: define socialism. His answer, according to Dave Smith and Robbie "The Fire" Bernstein on Part of the Problem, was not a definition of an economic system but a pitch for a magical outcome. "Socialism to me," Adams said, "means that you will have whatever you need to live a dignified life and that it is the government's job to deliver on that."

Smith and Bernstein spend the episode dismantling this answer, arguing that it is intellectually empty, emotionally manipulative, and a dangerous invitation to expand the state's coercive power. The central argument is that Adams never defines socialism as a mechanism—he simply describes a desired result (everyone has dignity and stuff) and skips the entire question of how that result is achieved without force, without incentives, and without accounting for cost.

The Conflation of Outcomes with Systems

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (04:00) **Introducing the Mamdani Clip** - Dave sets up a viral clip of New York City Mayor Eric Adams (referred to as "Mamdani") on Theo Vaughn's podcast, defending Theo's decision to host him as good for conversation and exposing bad ideas.
  • 2 (09:57) **Mamdani's Definition: "Dignity" and Government's Job** - The clip plays: Mamdani says socialism means everyone has what they need for a dignified life, and it's the government's job to deliver that.
  • 3 (14:15) **"Extending Democracy" to the Rest of Life** - Mamdani argues socialism extends democratic power from the ballot box to the workplace and home, giving people choice in all areas.
  • 4 (23:20) **Democratizing the Workplace and Home** - Mamdani specifically mentions extending democracy to the workplace and home; Dave and Rob are baffled by the home part.
  • 5 (26:58) **The Gene Epstein Argument: Voluntary Socialism** - Dave introduces economist Gene Epstein's point that workers already have the power to form co-ops voluntarily, proving socialists don't actually want to do the work.
  • 6 (31:57) **Capital Investment and Time Preference** - Dave explains that socialism ignores the role of capital investment, which is the engine of business creation and job growth.
  • 7 (36:00) **The Empirical Evidence: East and West Germany, North and South Korea** - Dave argues that the theoretical case against socialism is overwhelming, but the empirical evidence is even more damning.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Show Notes

Dave Smith brings you the latest in politics! On this episode of Part Of The Problem, Dave and Robbie "the Fire" Bernstein discuss Mamdani's appearance on Theo Von's podcast, his definition of socialism, and more.


Support Our Sponsors:

Brunt Workwear - http://bruntworkwear.com/ Use code PROBLEM for $10 off your first order!


Cowboy Colostrum - Get 25% Off Cowboy Colostrum with code DAVE at https://www.cowboycolostrum.com/DAVE


The Wellness Company - Spike Detox your body! Click http://www.twc.health/problem and use code PROBLEM for 10% Off + Free Shipping for USA residents


Quince - Get free shipping on your Quince order and 365-day returns at

https://www.quince.com/POTP



Part Of The Problem is available for early pre-release at https://partoftheproblem.com as well as an exclusive episode on Thursday!


PORCH TOUR DATES HERE:

https://www.eventbrite.com/cc/porch-tour-2026-4836968



Find Run Your Mouth here:

YouTube - http://youtube.com/@RunYourMouth

iTunes - https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/run-your-mouth-podcast/id1211469807

Spotify - https://open.spotify.com/show/4ka50RAKTxFTxbtyPP8AHm


Follow the show on social media:

X:

http://x.com/ComicDaveSmith

http://x.com/RobbieTheFire


Instagram:

http://instagram.com/theproblemdavesmith

http://instagram.com/robbiethefire


#libertarian



See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.

Part Of The Problem

More from this podcast

Part Of The Problem →