Panic World
Panic World

BONUS PREVIEW: The Republicans forgot how to use the internet

November 6, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

The Republicans forgot how to use the internet

"The Republicans got completely trounced in the midterms," Ryan Broderick says on this emergency episode of Panic World. But the explanation he offers is not the one you'll find in most news coverage. It's not about candidate quality, abortion, or even inflation alone. Broderick's argument is that the Republican Party lost a major structural advantage they had spent nearly a decade cultivating: they forgot how to use the internet effectively, and specifically, they forgot about Instagram.

The Instagram blind spot

Broderick's central framework comes from research conducted by GDMI, the consulting arm of his media operation Garbage Day. The key insight is simple but easy to miss: "Instagram and Facebook are local and every other platform is non-local." TikTok, X (formerly Twitter), and other algorithmically driven platforms do not know who your friends and family are. They can guess, but they don't have a real local social graph. Instagram, because it absorbed Facebook's social infrastructure, does.

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (01:00) **Republicans Got Trounced and Forgot How to Use the Internet** - Ryan Broderick introduces the episode’s central thesis: Republicans lost the midterms because they abandoned local social platforms like Instagram in favor of national algorithmic feeds.
  • 2 (05:43) **GDMI’s Research: Instagram’s Local Anti-Trans Problem** - Broderick reveals how GDMI’s work for the Transgender Law Center uncovered that Instagram, not TikTok, is the primary vector for localized anti-trans messaging.
  • 3 (10:28) **The Epic Failure: Losing Young Men and Key Voter Blocs** - Broderick explains why he believes Republicans lost the midterms, tying it to a collapse in their coalition among young men, black voters, and Hispanic voters.
  • 4 (12:41) **The Instagram Psyop That Could Have Worked** - Broderick argues that a well-executed, hyper-local Instagram conspiracy campaign could have counteracted the negative effects of policy failures like data centers and high gas prices.
  • 5 (14:00) **The Trump Administration’s Populist Failure** - Broderick and the host discuss how the Trump administration abandoned its populist roots, with Broderick arguing Trump himself has never been good at populism.
  • 6 (17:27) **Dark Chungus and the Collapse of Republican Social Media Strategy** - Broderick names and shames the White House social media manager, Stephen Chung, as the embodiment of the GOP’s failed internet strategy.
  • 7 (18:43) **The Local-to-National Strategy Republicans Forgot** - Broderick explains the mechanism that made Republicans successful in the past: taking a local conspiracy and turning it into a national story.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Show Notes

On Tuesday’s midterms, the Democrats were finally not in disarray — and despite all the handwringing, we got a blue tsunami that was “too big to rig.” How did they do it, or perhaps more importantly, how did the Republicans mess this up so badly?

Ryan & Grant analyze the election results and submit that the GOP got too bad at the internet. Liberals abandoning Twitter after it became X left right-wingers in an echo chamber where they had no one to fight but themselves, and neglected all the other platforms they should’ve been focusing on.

Plus, are Democrats going through the party transformation the GOP did in the mid-2000s (except in a good way)? And is Trump really Hitler, or is he more like the kaiser who leads to the real baddie?

This is a preview from our Patreon. Want to hear the rest of the conversation, and enjoy other ad-free episodes, bonuses & exclusives, and access to our members-only Discord? Sign up for a membership for just $6.66 a month at https://www.patreon.com/PanicWorld.

⁠Buy tickets to Panic World’s FIRST-EVER LIVE SHOW⁠ on November 28 in NYC! Along with Katie Notopoulos, the Garbage Media team will inflict the worst things on the internet in 2026 upon an unsuspecting Grant. Get your tickets here, sickos: ⁠https://caveat.nyc/events/garbage-day-worst-things-on-the-internet-2026-2026-11-28⁠

Credits

- Host: Ryan Broderick

- Producer: Grant Irving

- Production Coordinator: Josh Fjelstad

- Researcher: Adam Bumas

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Panic World

More from this podcast

Panic World →