Otherworld
Otherworld

Jack & Chelsea [Patreon Preview]

September 16, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

Jack & Chelsea [Patreon Preview]

Jack Wagner, host of Otherworld, introduces a bonus episode featuring a couple named Jack and Chelsea — the same names as him and his wife, which he finds strangely coincidental. The story begins when Chelsea, then dating Jack, was living in an old brick house in the Northside neighborhood of Cincinnati. Jack moved in after returning from Kentucky, and what started as a lively, party-filled art house gradually turned into something far more unsettling.

The House on Cullen Avenue

The house was a three-story brick building from the late 1800s, one of several similar structures on a quiet residential street. Jack describes it as "decrepit" — cracked linoleum floors, missing trim, and a basement that was "weird" from the start, with an almost dirt floor. But the overall atmosphere was positive. "When I first moved into the house, I felt nothing but good vibes," Jack says. The place was constantly full of roommates, friends, musicians, and artists. There were parties, late nights, and a sense of creative energy. Jack was studying photojournalism and spent many Monday nights at a local bar called The Comet, where a friend ran a music series. He would photograph the bands, stay until closing around 2:30 or 3:00 AM, and then walk home.

The First Strange Sound

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (00:13) **Host Introduction & Episode Setup** - Jack Wagner introduces the bonus episode, noting the strange coincidence that the storytellers share his and his wife's names.
  • 2 (02:33) **Jack’s Background & The House’s Vibe** - Jack Ellenberger introduces himself and describes the initial positive atmosphere of the Northside house.
  • 3 (09:58) **The First Strange Event: The Tinkling Sound** - After a late night out, Jack experiences an unexplained sound that reacts to his movement.
  • 4 (13:33) **Preview Conclusion** - The preview ends with Jack's first encounter, directing listeners to the full episode on Patreon.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Show Notes

For Jack & Chelsea, what began as an exciting move into a charming, historic Cincinnati house full of parties and roommates devolved into a nightmare. At first, strange things began happening that were infrequent and easy to write off... hearing strange sounds, or an entire load of laundry vanishing then things escalated quickly, culminating in multiple events that made these two confident that their house was extremely haunted.

For the full episode, sign up for the Otherworld Patreon at www.patreon.com/otherworld

Otherworld

More from this podcast

Otherworld →