What's the Point of God If God Doesn't Intervene? With Rabbi Yitz Greenberg (306)
October 5, 2026
AI Summary
5 min read“It's not Hashem's failure, it's Hashem wanted us to grow up and be autonomously responsible, to do it not for reward and not for punishment. This is the highest level of religion we've ever lived at.” Rabbi Yitz Greenberg, speaking on the Orthodox Conundrum podcast, has spent more than sixty years wrestling with what faith means after the Shoah. His central claim is that God is not absent or failing, but is instead increasingly hidden in order to call humanity to full maturity and responsibility. In this conversation with host Scott Kahn, Greenberg explains his understanding of Judaism as a religion of choosing life, why he has revised his famous idea of the “voluntary covenant,” what prayer means when God does not intervene in obvious ways, and why he believes Christianity may be part of God’s plan for the world.
Choosing Life as the Organizing Principle of Torah
Greenberg’s overarching thesis, developed over forty years and articulated in his two-volume collection Life Against Death, is that the entire Torah is about choosing life. He points to Moses’ summary in Deuteronomy: “I have put before you life and death, blessing and curse. Choose life.” The Rambam, Greenberg notes, understood this to mean that behind every mitzvah is a choice for life, and behind every transgression is an element of choice for death.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Orthodox Conundrum
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:00) **Episode Introduction & Guest Background** - Host Scott Kahn introduces the central question of the episode: what is the point of God if God does not intervene, and frames the conversation with Rabbi Yitz Greenberg's core claim that God expects human responsibility.
- 2 (07:04) **"Life Against Death" as the Organizing Principle of Judaism** - Rabbi Greenberg explains that his title is a tribute to his larger thesis that Judaism is a religion of life, and that every mitzvah is a choice between life and death.
- 3 (16:19) **Defining "Life": Physical, Spiritual, and the Three Exceptions** - Host Scott Kahn presses for a precise definition of "life," asking if it is merely biological or something more expansive, and raises the challenge of the three sins for which one must die rather than transgress.
- 4 (27:11) **The Voluntary Covenant: From Divine Failure to Divine Invitation** - Scott Kahn asks how God's hiddenness, the voluntary covenant, and the experience of God in this world all work together, prompting Greenberg to trace the evolution of his own thinking on the covenant.
- 5 (37:12) **Religious Pluralism and the Two Levels of Covenant** - Scott Kahn asks whether Greenberg's revised view of the covenant changes his approach to non-Orthodox Jews, who are no longer seen as simply opting out of a voluntary covenant.
- 6 (43:04) **Hester Panim: God Hidden to Come Closer, Not to Withdraw** - Rabbi Greenberg reframes the concept of divine hiddenness, arguing that God's increasing hiddenness is not a withdrawal but an invitation to intimacy.
- 7 (50:55) **"What's the Point of a God Who is So Hidden?"** - Scott Kahn poses the central challenge: if a researcher can do God's work without believing in God, what difference does God actually make?
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
Check out Orthodox Conundrum Commentary on Substack and get your free subscription by going to https://scottkahn.substack.com/ - and members get this and other episodes of the Orthodox Conundrum Podcast ad-free and with early access and additional bonus content!
What's the point of God if God doesn't intervene?
Rabbi Yitz Greenberg has spent more than sixty years wrestling with the meaning of faith after the Holocaust, and one of his central claims is that God increasingly expects human beings to take responsibility for the world rather than waiting for divine intervention. But if that's true, what role does God actually play? And what does it mean for covenant, religious obligation, and prayer?
In this conversation, we discuss Rabbi Greenberg's understanding of Judaism as a religion that demands that we "choose life"; why he has significantly revised his famous idea of the "voluntary covenant"; why he believes God's increasing hiddenness represents not divine absence, but a more mature stage in the relationship between God and humanity; and what all of this means for the relationship between Orthodox and non-Orthodox Jews.
We also discuss one of his more controversial claims: that Christianity may itself be part of God's plan for bringing the biblical message to humanity. And finally, I ask what prayer means in a world where God increasingly leaves the work to us. When we ask God to heal, to provide justice, or to repair what is broken, are we asking God to act, or are we accepting responsibility to act on God's behalf?
This is a wide-ranging conversation about God, Torah, the Holocaust, religious pluralism, Christianity, human responsibility, and what faith means in a world where God may not intervene in the ways that we expect.
Listen to the new Naaseh weekly podcast!
Each week, host Ari Levisohn, joined by Rav Jeremy Tibbetts or Lazar Berman, starts with a close reading of the Parsha and asks what happens when we try to actually live it - not only in our own lives, but in the communities we create - and the kind of society we're trying to build. Because Torah isn't only meant to describe a better world. It's meant to help us build one. The Bereishit episode of Naaseh is out now. Find it on Spotify, Apple Podcasts , or YouTube. Rabbi Yitz Greenberg just released his new two volume set of classic essays, Life Against Death. Listeners to Orthodox Conundrum in the United States and Canada will receive a 40% discount, and a 50% discount for bulk pu More from this podcast
Orthodox Conundrum →