AI Summary
5 min readNew York City’s Department of Sanitation (DSNY) picks up, processes, and exports 24 million pounds of trash, recycling, and compostable material every single day. Deputy Commissioner Joshua Goodman describes this as the “definitional Sisyphean task”: the boulder never stops, and there is no final victory lap. Yet for decades, the city has relied on a system that is famously ugly, smelly, and rat-friendly: black plastic bags piled on the curb. Goodman joins Odd Lots to explain why that system persisted, what it took to finally start changing it, and how the city is now engineering a “trash revolution” that will fundamentally reshape the streetscape.
Why New York Piles Bags on the Curb
The city’s distinctive trash problem has two historical roots. First, the 1811 street grid was laid out without alleyways—unlike Chicago or many European cities, there was no dedicated back-of-building space to store waste. Second, after the 1968 sanitation strike left mountains of garbage, Mayor John Lindsay convened a “Committee on the Black Bag.” The plastics industry promoted black bags as rodent-resistant, and the city adopted them as a replacement for metal cans. “Obviously it became clear almost immediately that that was not the case,” Goodman says, but the system stuck for five decades.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Odd Lots
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (01:41) **Why Trash Collection Is Political** - The hosts introduce Joshua Goodman, Deputy Commissioner of NYC’s Department of Sanitation, and challenge the famous LaGuardia quote that trash pickup is apolitical.
- 2 (04:44) **The “Trash Revolution” Framework** - Goodman describes a complete reimagining of how 8.5 million New Yorkers interact with their waste, driven by data and a willingness to abandon the status quo.
- 3 (08:54) **How Black Bags Became NYC’s Signature** - Two historical events created New York’s unique trash problem: the 1811 street grid (no alleys) and the 1968 sanitation strike.
- 4 (10:58) **The Ideological Frameworks Behind Cleanliness** - Goodman explains that different political choices about who to prioritize — drivers vs. pedestrians, the rat-tolerant vs. the rat-phobic — make trash collection inherently ideological.
- 5 (14:43) **The Current Waste Journey: Curb to Export** - Goodman walks through the lifecycle of a trash bag from a Soho apartment to its final destination, explaining the infrastructure built after the Staten Island landfill closed.
- 6 (16:34) **Recycling and Composting: Not a Scam in NYC** - Goodman pushes back on the popular “recycling is a scam” narrative, explaining that NYC’s long-term contracts guarantee beneficial reuse of properly sorted materials.
- 7 (20:25) **The New Front-of-House Regime** - After the back-of-house changes (2000-2015) that built the transfer stations, the city is now transforming how residents interact with trash through on-street containerization.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
According to Joshua Goodman, trash collection in New York is one of the last services the city offers that is not yet touched by neoliberalism. What he means is that it's the last free and unlimited city service — there is no opt-in; it is not means tested. Goodman — who is the DSNY's deputy commissioner for public affairs and customer experience — tells us that the city deals with 24 million pounds of trash every day, and on today's podcast, he explains the logistical dance required to sort through all that garbage. We also get into why NYC produces less trash than you might think, the DSNY's new containerization program (and the new side-loading trucks they built in less than 18 months), and why recycling is not a scam.
Only Bloomberg.com subscribers can get the Odd Lots newsletter in their inbox, plus unlimited access to the site and app. bloomberg.com/subscriptions/oddlots
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.