New Books in Islamic Studies
New Books in Islamic Studies

Youssef J. Carter, "The Vast Oceans: Remembering Allah and Self on the Mustafawiyya Sufi Path" (UNC Press, 2026)

June 19, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

Youssef J. Carter’s new book, The Vast Oceans: Remembering Allah and Self on the Mustafawiyya Sufi Path, opens not with a thesis statement but with a confession: the author is not sure he is an anthropologist. He holds a doctorate in cultural anthropology from UC Berkeley, but he identifies as a Black Muslim anthropologist—a distinction that signals his intellectual and political commitments. The book is an ethnographic meditation on the Mustafawiyya Sufi community as it moves between South Carolina and Senegal, following the legacy of Shaykh Harun Nafai and his teacher Shaykh Mustafa. But it is also a sustained argument for what Carter calls “Black Muslim study”: a framework that brings together the political urgency of Black studies with the spiritual and epistemological resources of Islamic philosophy and Sufi practice.

A Journey, Not a Linear Argument

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (03:12) **Intellectual Journey to the Book** - Carter recounts his path from biology to Black diaspora studies, a pivot from Paris fieldwork to studying the Mustafawiyya community in South Carolina after his wife’s encouragement.
  • 2 (09:41) **Identity as a Black Muslim Ethnographer** - Carter explains his hesitation to claim the label “anthropologist,” grounding his work in Black studies and Sufi epistemology rather than disciplinary anthropology.
  • 3 (15:33) **Structuring the Book Through Sufi Concepts** - The book is organized around key Sufi terms (baya, zikr, ziyara, khidma, tazkiya, shifa) rendered into new conceptual frameworks to reflect community language.
  • 4 (24:16) **Repair and the Soul: Racism as Spiritual Disease** - Carter argues dismantling structural racism requires addressing how race inhabits the soul, citing the hadith on the heart’s soundness.
  • 5 (30:46) **The Black Muslim Atlantic Framework** - Carter explains the importance of theorizing Black Atlantic Sufism, moving beyond apolitical readings of Sufism and emphasizing transnational Black Muslim world-making.
  • 6 (41:43) **Ziyara as Movement and Commemoration** - The chapter traces pilgrimage routes between Senegal and South Carolina, comparing mausoleums, museums, and mosques as commemorative sites that shape identity.
  • 7 (48:59) **Khidma and the Labor of Motherwork** - Carter’s favorite chapter honors the reproductive and spiritual labor of Black Muslim women, centering Umm Aisha and Umm Khadija as foundational to the tariqa.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

Youssef J. Carter’s The Vast Oceans: Remembering Allah and Self on the Mustafawiyya Sufi Path (UNC Press, 2026) is a stunning meditation on Black Atlantic Sufism, specifically as it travels between South Carolina and Senegal via the Mustafawiyya Sufi community and Shaykh Arona Faye. The book orbits around Sufi conceptual frameworks which are translated through the register of Black and Africana Studies. For example, bay’a is rendered as “solidarity” or khidma as “labour”; such attunement of Sufi concepts presents capacious possibilities for Sufi studies at the intersection of Black and Muslim studies. The book then uses deep ethnography to capture the flows of stories, rituals, and piety, and also Black radical labour, motherwork, and becoming to highlight how in spite of the ongoing violence of racial capitalism and plantation modernity, Black-Africana Sufi communities are vital spaces of worldmaking, one that is not merely metaphysical (such as through ritual piety) but also political, anti-racist, and anti-colonial and rooted in collective care. This book is necessary reading for scholars of Sufism, and those who work on Black and African Islam.

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Support our show by becoming a premium member! https://newbooksnetwork.supportingcast.fm/islamic-studies

New Books in Islamic Studies

More from this podcast

New Books in Islamic Studies →