I Found a Painting of My Childhood Home at Goodwill.
August 5, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readI found a painting of my childhood home at Goodwill. It was hanging on the wall in a store on the other side of the country from where I grew up. I knew it was my house—the oak tree, the roses, even the railing I broke trying to do a ballet spin as a kid. My husband Parker thought it could just be a cookie-cutter suburban house that looked similar. But when I sent a photo to my mom, she confirmed it: that was our house. The painting was real, with visible brushstrokes and graphite marks under the paint. A faded sticker on the back read "Cozy Home Portraits Company." The elderly Goodwill employee, Marge, said she remembered a company that would paint portraits of homes for homeowners. But when I got home and started researching, I found almost nothing—just Reddit threads from other people who had found similar paintings of their childhood homes, with no explanation.
The painter and the memory
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Mr. Creeps: Scary Stories & Creepypastas
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:55) **The Discovery** - At a Goodwill across the country from her childhood home, the narrator finds an oil painting that is an exact replica of the house she grew up in.
- 2 (05:42) **The Signature and Marge** - A Goodwill employee named Marge helps decipher the artist's signature, identifying it as "George Moffat," and explains the likely origin of the painting.
- 3 (09:02) **The Online Rabbit Hole** - The narrator's research into the Cozy Home Portraits Company turns up almost nothing, only finding Reddit threads from others with similar experiences.
- 4 (12:04) **The Sense of Dread** - A growing, inexplicable sense of dread takes hold of the narrator, which she discusses with Parker before bed.
- 5 (14:22) **The First Anomaly** - The narrator is unable to sleep and notices their front porch light has turned on, followed by a noise from the kitchen.
- 6 (18:08) **The Call to Mom** - The narrator calls her mother to ask about the painting and the artist, leading to a major breakthrough in the case.
- 7 (22:10) **Finding Craig Moffat** - The narrator finds a website dedicated to Craig Moffat's art, confirming his identity and his disturbing past.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
Where'd this come from? Written by: SunHeadPrime
More from this podcast
Mr. Creeps: Scary Stories & Creepypastas →