Modern Wisdom
Modern Wisdom

Why Atheists Keep Finding God (in everything) - Alex O’Connor - #1175

November 12, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

Alex O’Connor, who now prefers “agnostic” to “atheist,” has spent a decade publicly picking apart arguments for God’s existence. Yet he regularly hears from theists who say his work strengthened their faith. That paradox drives this conversation: O’Connor argues that the foundational questions of philosophy—God, consciousness, the nature of reality—are not problems to be solved by better arguments. They are experiential phenomena, and mistaking them for logic puzzles leads to a kind of misplaced certainty.

The limits of argument and the role of experience

O’Connor’s central claim is that philosophy of religion is not like physics. In physics, each generation builds on the last. In philosophy, “everybody starts in the same place. We're battling with the exact same questions as Plato and the ancients. There's no progress to be made because philosophy is not about establishing consensus through arguments which cannot be refuted.” The reason, he says, is that religious belief is ultimately grounded in experience, not inference. He points to Thomas Aquinas, who left the Summa Theologica unfinished after a mystical experience during the Eucharist, reportedly saying, “Everything is like straw compared to what I've seen.” Blaise Pascal, after his 1654 vision, wrote in his diary of “the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, the God of Jacob, the God of Jesus Christ, not the God of t

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (00:22) **From Debate Bro to Philosophical Explorer** - Alex O’Connor explains his shift away from militant atheism toward a more open, agnostic stance.
  • 2 (08:48) **Why People Believe for Bad Reasons** - Alex uses the flat-earth analogy to argue that most people, theists and atheists alike, hold their positions on shaky grounds.
  • 3 (13:05) **The Limits of Sterile Intellectualism** - Chris recounts the story of Ayaan Hirsi Ali's emotional conversion story being met with Richard Dawkins' skeptical questions, highlighting a cultural shift towards empathy.
  • 4 (19:34) **The Universal Religious Impulse** - Alex explores whether early humans had religious experiences and distinguishes between belief in gods and belief in a singular, foundational God.
  • 5 (27:54) **Consciousness: The Hardest Problem** - Alex argues that consciousness is the foundational philosophical question and a profound limit for science and materialism.
  • 6 (34:01) **Why Science Can't Explain Experience** - Alex uses the example of a blind scientist who learns everything about color but still learns something new when they regain sight to illustrate the failure of materialism.
  • 7 (43:49) **From Materialism to a Conscious Foundation** - Alex explains that studying consciousness makes materialism hard to defend, but doesn't automatically lead to God; it opens the door to idealism or panpsychism.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

Alex O’Connor is a YouTuber, writer and a podcaster.

Expect to learn what shifts happened in Alex’s thinking these past few years, why you actually would ever want to time travel, why so many people are moving away from atheism, why consciousness is the biggest hole in the atheist argument, what meditation really does to your conscious mind, if there is a practical point to prayer, if watching porn is considered cheating, and much more...

Sponsors:

Get 160+ lab tests for just $365 and save an extra $25 at ⁠https://functionhealth.com/modernwisdom⁠

Get 35% off your first subscription to the best supplements from Momentous at ⁠https://livemomentous.com/modernwisdom⁠

Sign up for a free trial from Shopify at ⁠https://shopify.com/modernwisdom⁠

Get 15% off your first order of my favourite Non-Alcoholic Brew at ⁠https://athleticbrewing.com/modernwisdom⁠

See discounts for all the products I use and recommend: ⁠⁠https://chriswillx.com/deals⁠⁠

Get ChatGPT to explore ideas, solve problems, and learn faster at ⁠⁠https://chatgpt.com⁠

Extra Stuff:

Get my free reading list of 100 books to read before you die: ⁠https://chriswillx.com/books⁠

Try my productivity energy drink Neutonic: ⁠https://neutonic.com/modernwisdom⁠

Episodes You Might Enjoy:

#577 - David Goggins - This Is How To Master Your Life: ⁠lnkfi.re/SN-Goggins⁠

#712 - Dr Jordan Peterson - How To Destroy Your Negative Beliefs: ⁠lnkfi.re/SN-Peterson⁠

#700 - Dr Andrew Huberman - The Secret Tools To Hack Your Brain: ⁠lnkfi.re/SN-Huberman⁠

-

Get In Touch:

Instagram: ⁠https://www.instagram.com/chriswillx⁠

Twitter: ⁠https://www.twitter.com/chriswillx⁠

YouTube: ⁠https://www.youtube.com/modernwisdompodcast⁠

Email: ⁠https://chriswillx.com/contact⁠

-

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices

Modern Wisdom