I'm a Paramedic in a Small Lake Town. Something Terrifying Roams at Night.

August 5, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

A paramedic named Jose moved from Cleveland to the small lake town of Port Clinton, Ohio, looking for quieter work. Instead, he walked into a midnight call at Simpson Bait and Tackle that changed everything. The owner, Dean, was gone. The front door stood open, a mug of coffee was still steaming on the counter, and the cash register was full. Dean's rubber fishing boots sat beside the entrance mat, laces still tied in double knots. There was no mud on the floor, no wet footprints, and no tracks leading from the shop toward the lake. Behind the building, the cattails were flattened in a wide band and coated in a clear, oily slime. Jose found no sign of a struggle, no boat wake, and no disturbed mud. Dean had simply vanished.

The Pattern Emerges

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

Listen to Audio Summary Open in App

Never miss an episode of Insomnia Stories Podcast

Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

What you'll learn

1 Main Outline
2 (00:45) **First Call: Dean Simpson Vanishes from Bait Shop** - Paramedic Jose arrives at Simpson Bait and Tackle to find the door open, coffee still steaming, and Dean's boots left behind with laces still tied in double knots.
3 (07:55) **The Ambulance's Secret Equipment** - Jose notices the ambulance carries a heavy padlock and rope that are never used on ordinary calls.
4 (08:57) **Return to the Bait Shop** - Jose retrieves his medical bag two days later and finds Dean's boots still untouched by the mat.
5 (12:00) **Jason Suppresses the Evidence** - Station supervisor Jason takes Jose's report and photographs, then tells him "we'll handle the official version."
6 (15:57) **Warren Tests the Padlock Before Every Call** - Warren stops at the rear doors before driving and checks the heavy padlock.
7 (17:03) **Second Disappearance: Hudson Bailey at the Marina** - A welder vanishes from a platform, leaving his welding mask and work boots behind.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

I'm a Paramedic in a Small Lake Town. Something Terrifying Roams at Night.