Fresh Air
Fresh Air

How the killing of Jordan Neely on the NYC subway divided America

October 28, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

How the killing of Jordan Neely on the NYC subway divided America

In May 2023, Jordan Neely boarded a New York City subway car in crisis. He was homeless, living with serious mental illness, and shouting threats. Passengers were afraid. A former Marine named Daniel Penny stepped in and put Neely in a chokehold for six minutes. Neely died, and a video of the encounter divided the country. To some, Penny was a man doing what police couldn't. To others, Neely was another Black man whose life had been treated as disposable. Penny was acquitted of criminally negligent homicide in December 2024. Within days, Vice President-elect J.D. Vance invited him to the Army-Navy game alongside President-elect Trump. A Silicon Valley venture capital firm gave him a job. Journalist Anan Girdadas spent more than two years investigating what the video couldn't show, and his new book Man in the Mirror asks a question that goes far beyond that subway car: What happens to a country when people lose faith in systems and start taking matters into their own hands?

The narrative machinery

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (00:00) **Introduction: The Jordan Neely Case and its Aftermath** - Host Tanya Mosely sets up the story: Jordan Neely, a Michael Jackson impersonator, died after a chokehold by former Marine Daniel Penny on a NYC subway in May 2023. The case and acquittal divided the country.
  • 2 (02:17) **The Battle Over the Narrative** - Girdadas explains how powerful lawyers, political figures, and activists immediately worked to shape how Jordan Neely and Daniel Penny were seen, turning them into caricatures.
  • 3 (04:13) **The Central Emotion: Abandonment** - Girdadas identifies a shared feeling of abandonment that connected everyone in the subway car: Jordan Neely, Daniel Penny, and the passengers.
  • 4 (05:55) **How the Context Has Changed Since the 1980s** - Girdadas contrasts the high-crime era of the 1980s with the post-COVID reality of the 2020s.
  • 5 (08:31) **Jordan Neely's Story: From Thriving to Crisis** - The investigation reveals Neely's life began to fall apart when his mother was murdered by her boyfriend when he was 14.
  • 6 (11:49) **The Missed Chance to Save Neely** - Girdadas uncovers an internal memo showing the city came heartbreakingly close to getting Neely off the streets just three weeks before his death.
  • 7 (14:05) **Daniel Penny's World: West Islip and the Fear of the City** - Girdadas explores Penny's upbringing in a Long Island town shaped by "white flight," which he describes as a "middle class refugee camp" from the terror of New York City.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

Jordan Neely, a Black unhoused man in crisis, was frightening fellow passengers on the New York City Subway. A white former Marine named Daniel Penny put Neely into a chokehold, killing him. Journalist Anand Giridharadas investigates the incident, and what it reveals about American society in Man in the Mirror. He spoke with Tonya Mosley. 

John Powers reviews the Thomas Mann film Fatherland.

Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter 
Follow us on Instagram 
Subscribe to our YouTube channel 
Check out the Fresh Air Archives

See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences.

NPR Privacy Policy
Fresh Air

More from this podcast

Fresh Air →