Week 4 Fantasy Football News: Puka Nacua, Braelon Allen, J.J. McCarthy & Start/Sit Advice (Ep. 2233)
October 1, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readThe New England Patriots are calling it a right shoulder injury, but Drake Maye’s struggles have been the dominant story of their 0-3 start, and now there’s a medical explanation to go with the tape. On this episode of the FantasyPros Tailgate, Andrew Erickson runs through the top five storylines heading into Week 4, starting with breaking news that Puka Nacua is expected to play against the Eagles. The episode covers shifting backfields in Miami and New York, a critical secondary injury in Carolina that sets up a potential Jameson Williams explosion, the Chicago Bears’ quarterback dilemma, and the fallout from the J.J. McCarthy trade to the Giants.
Puka Nacua Returns, But the Injury Cloud Lingers
Adam Schefter reported that Rams head coach Sean McVay expects Puka Nacua to play in Week 4 against the Philadelphia Eagles. For fantasy managers who have held him through a groin/hip/sports hernia issue that has been reported inconsistently, this is the green light they needed. Erickson acknowledges the risk of a pitch count but is unequivocal: “You're gonna fire this guy up no matter what.” He draws a parallel to a Thursday night game in Nacua’s rookie year when he was questionable and then “absolutely smashed,” as well as Brock Bowers’ nuclear return in Week 3. The caveat remains that the injury could require surgery down the line, but for Week 4, Nacua is a start.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 Week 4 Fantasy Football News: Puka Nacua, Braelon Allen, J.J. McCarthy & Start/Sit Advice (Ep. 2233)
- 2 (01:18) **Puka Nacua Expected to Play in Week 4** - Breaking news: Rams star WR reported to play Sunday vs. Eagles per Sean McVay
- 3 (03:16) **Drake Maye Shoulder Injury Update** - Patriots QB pops up on injury report with right shoulder issue but was full participant in practice
- 4 (05:26) **Dolphins Backfield: Raheem Mostert vs. De'Von Achane** - Who emerges as Miami's RB1 facing a brutal Vikings matchup?
- 5 (07:54) **Start/Sit Advice: Aaron Jones and Flex Options** - Answering viewer questions on lineup decisions for Week 4
- 6 (10:23) **Braelon Allen Emerging for Jets** - Young running back poised for bigger role with Breece Hall dealing with thigh bruise
- 7 (13:30) **Trade and Roster Questions** - Evaluating several viewer trade scenarios for rest of season
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
Andrew Erickson goes solo on The Tailgate to tackle the biggest fantasy football storylines heading into NFL Week 4, starting with Puka Nacua’s expected return to the Rams lineup and the latest concern surrounding Drake Maye’s shoulder.
The injuries at running back have created new opportunities for Ollie Gordon II in Miami and Braelon Allen with the Jets, while Jameson Williams suddenly has an intriguing matchup against a depleted Panthers secondary.
Erickson also answers live start/sit and trade questions before looking at the Bears’ quarterback situation and what J.J. McCarthy’s move to the Giants could mean for Malik Nabers and the New York offense.
Timestamps: (May be off due to ads)
Intro - 0:00:00
Puka Nacua Returns - 0:00:40
Drake Maye Shoulder Injury - 0:02:35
Ollie Gordon - 0:04:44
Start Aaron Jones? - 0:07:21
Jersey Giveaway - 0:09:07
Braelon Allen - 0:09:40
Kyren Williams + Burden or Monty rest of season? - 0:12:30
Drop Rachaad White - 0:13:47
Bench Egbuka? - 0:14:16
Trade Christian Watson for Breece Hall? - 0:15:07
Mike Jackson and Jaycee Horn on IR - 0:16:39
Polymarket - 0:18:15
Who Will QB Chicago in Wk4? - 0:19:02
Mike Evans not practicing - 0:21:28
Make a Trade in an 8 Team League? - 0:22:13
Herbert for Geno? - 0:23:42
Jadarian Price Nightmare - 0:24:18
JJ McCarthy to New York Giants - 0:30:15
See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
More from this podcast
FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast →