The Extra Point | Week 6 Fantasy Football Advice: Start/Sit Calls, Trade Targets & Players to Stash (Ep. 2253)

October 10, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

FantasyPros' "The Extra Point" episode is a live Discord Q&A session hosted by Scott Bogman and Tara Roberts, stepping in for the usual hosts. The conversation is a rapid-fire series of listener questions about lineup decisions, trade evaluations, and dynasty strategy. The core value of the episode is not in grand theories but in the concrete, conditional reasoning the hosts apply to specific player situations, revealing how they weigh volume, matchup, injury reports, and market psychology in real time.

The Art of the Conditional Start/Sit

The hosts repeatedly demonstrate that a start/sit decision is rarely a simple "Player X is better than Player Y." Instead, it is a conditional judgment that hinges on a single piece of late-breaking information. The clearest example is the question about Trayveon Henderson versus Emmanuel Wilson. Both Bogman and Roberts agreed that the choice depended entirely on the health of Rhamondre Stevenson. If Stevenson is active, Emmanuel Wilson gets the nod based on his recent explosive play and clear role in Green Bay's offense. If Stevenson is out, Henderson vaults ahead because of the sheer volume he would inherit against a favorable Vegas defense. The reasoning is not about talent but about opportunity cost: "the volume makes the floor so high."

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

Listen to Audio Summary Open in App

Never miss an episode of FantasyPros - Fantasy Football Podcast

Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

What you'll learn

1 (00:42) **Opening & Host Intro** - Scott Bogman and Tara Roberts welcome listeners to the Discord AMA, covering for the usual hosts who are off.
2 (02:46) **Dynasty Rebuild: Buy-Low Targets & 2027 Pick Strategy** - Catalyst asks about trading a late first-round pick for a buy-low running back like De'Von Achane during a rebuild.
3 (06:15) **Start/Sit: Emmanuel Wilson vs. Trayveon Henderson** - Joe seeks a flex option among Emmanuel Wilson, Trayveon Henderson, Deebo Samuel, and others in half-PPR.
4 (08:36) **Start/Sit: Alvin Kamara vs. Will Shipley** - Joe asks about starting either Kamara or Shipley as his RB2 in full-PPR, questioning whether to trust the FantasyPros app.
5 (11:13) **Trade Advice: Selling High on Ollie Gordon** - Sully considers trading Ollie Gordon for Matthew Stafford to fix a QB need with Caleb Williams out.
6 (12:54) **Tight End Stash: Michael Mayer** - Cornwallis pitches Michael Mayer as a slept-on TE stash, citing the Raiders' heavy 12-personnel usage and Bowers drawing top coverage.
7 (16:09) **Redraft Panic: 0-8 Start & Selling High** - Really Him, in a redraft league with an 0-8 record, asks if he should trade Tet McMillan and Bayshall after a big game.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Scott Bogman Tara Roberts

Show Notes

Scott Bogman and Tera Roberts are answering your fantasy football questions with Week 6 lineup decisions looming. Should Jacoby Brissett start over Jalen Hurts? Can you trust Emmanuel Wilson, and how much would a Rhamondre Stevenson absence change TreVeyon Henderson's outlook?

They also tackle trade strategy for contenders and struggling teams, Michael Mayer's sleeper appeal and a massive dynasty offer involving CeeDee Lamb.

It's a full slate of start/sit, trade and roster questions pulled directly from the FantasyPros Discord.

Timestamps: (May be off due to ads)

Intro - 0:00:00

FantasyPros Discord - 0:00:29

Arizona vs Detroit - 0:01:05

Trade for Achane in a Rebuild? - 0:02:05

Ugly Flex Situation - 0:05:33

Kamara or Shipley - 0:08:00

Which Side of This Trade? - 0:10:30

Fix My TE Position - 0:12:14

Time To Be Aggressive with Trades? - 0:16:31

Jaylen Waddle and Tuten for James Cook? - 0:19:47

Polymarket - 0:22:11

Trevor Lawrence vs Drake Maye - 0:22:54

Darius Cooper or Jaylen Wright? - 0:26:13

Need Help at Running Back - 0:28:47

Trade Zay Flowers - 0:30:45

Trade Luther Burden? - 0:32:46

FantasyPros App - 0:36:34

Out on Jalen Hurts, Start Brissett Instead? - 0:37:22

How High is Jacoby Brissett Ranked? - 0:41:42

Start Allgeier this Week? - 0:42:50

Move on From Christian Watson? - 0:47:30

Nabers, Rhamondre & Montgomery for Jeanty and Corum? - 0:49:20

Trading Away Christian Watson - 0:52:10

4-0, Do I Set D'Andre Swift? - 0:55:40

Helpful Links:

Polymarket - Polymarket is giving you a $50 bonus when you deposit just $10. Sign up right now with promo code FPPOD at https://app.polymarket.us/S8ac/FPPOD. 18+ Only. Restrictions and eligibility requirements apply. Not available in all jurisdictions. Trading is risky. 100% loss can occur. See http://polymarket.com/tos for more information. The Polymarket US App serves as an independent software provider and affiliate of Polymarket US and Polymarket Clearing, the CFTC-regulated exchange and clearing organization.

My Playbook - Sync your league instantly to My Playbook to get custom advice on how to manage your team throughout the season. See your league’s top available players, power rankings, and more for free! Check the “Are They Playing” tool each week to get the latest game-day availability odds for all injured players. If you’re premium – you unlock all kinds of helpful waiver, trade, lineup and league analysis tools. You can even auto-start your team’s optimal lineup each week with Auto-Pilot. Sync your league and dominate every week of the season with My Playbook at fantasypros.com/myplaybo