AI Summary
5 min readBuild vs. Buy: What Experienced Investors Actually Know About Old Houses
When BiggerPockets host Dave Meyer looked back on his first eight years of investing, every single property he bought was built before 1940—1890s, 1920s, whatever he could afford in Colorado. That experience taught him something most newer investors miss: old houses aren't automatically bad investments. They just require a different playbook, one that separates the systems that can bankrupt you from the ones that cost less than you'd expect.
The Real Risk in Older Properties
Henry Washington puts it bluntly: "Foundation work is the number one thing that's going to cause you a big pain in the butt." Some older homes sit on cinder block foundations that are structurally unstable, and even after spending $20,000 to $50,000 to fix them, "the house still is sloped and wobbly." You can't always completely remedy these problems, which matters when you eventually try to sell.
Plumbing runs a close second. Washington is currently re-plumbing an entire house—a project that has dragged on for nine months and cost $80,000. That's the kind of expense that turns a promising rental into a long-term money pit.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:03) **Old Houses as Investment Opportunities** - The episode opens by challenging the instinct to avoid pre-1960s homes, arguing that filtering out older inventory can cause investors to miss the best deals in many markets.
- 2 (01:29) **Question 1: Build vs. Buy for a First House Hack** - Kyler in Oxford, Alabama asks whether to build a duplex using an FHA construction loan instead of buying existing, given a lack of multi-family inventory.
- 3 (06:33) **Question 2: Expanding a Buy Box to Pre-1960s Properties** - Nicole in Columbus, Ohio asks for advice on buying older homes after avoiding them due to knob-and-tube wiring.
- 4 (09:46) **Dave’s Experience with Older Homes & The Sweet Spot Era** - Dave shares his early investing in 1890s–1920s homes and explains how to evaluate them safely.
- 5 (14:19) **Ad Break** - (Skipped per instructions)
- 6 (17:50) **Question 3: How Detailed Should a Rehab Budget Be for Lenders?** - Allie in Houston asks what makes a rehab budget “lender-ready” for hard money or renovation loans.
- 7 (24:16) **Question 4: Should a House Hacker Hide Their Ownership?** - Andrea in Houston asks for tips on minimizing issues when living in a duplex and renting the other unit without tenants knowing she’s the owner.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Guests on this episode
Show Notes
You don’t have to buy your first rental property—you can build one instead. Newer systems, fewer repairs, and that “brand new” feeling that tenants may pay more rent for. But…is it worth it? Building a small multifamily in a single-family area could let you house hack and own a rare property in your market, but is the headache worth the effort?
With more and more investors choosing to build rather than buy, we thought we’d weigh in.
Dave and Henry are back answering your questions from the BiggerPockets Forums. Today, we’re talking about building vs. buying rentals, when an investment property is too old to be worth buying, the lender-friendly rehab budget Henry uses to get loans for his BRRRRs (buy, rehab, rent, refinance, repeat) and house flips, and whether wholesalers (middlemen) are worth buying properties from.
Plus, if you’re house hacking, should you tell the tenant you’re the owner? Dave tried to hide it before, and shares whether it was worth it.
In This Episode We Cover
Building vs. buying rental properties: is the time (and effort) worth the upside?
Renovating an older rental property? This build decade could be best
Henry’s exact renovation budget he shares with lenders to get fast financing
Are wholesalers worth their assignment fee? When we will and won’t buy from them
Should you tell your tenants that you’re the owner (what happens if they find out?)
And So Much More!
Check out more resources from this show on
More from this podcast
BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast →