BRRRR vs. New Construction: Which Makes More Money in 2026 (I Did the Math)

August 28, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

BRRRR vs. New Construction: Which Makes More Money in 2026?

For the first time in decades, the math on buying a newly built home as a rental property is worth taking seriously. Builders are sitting on unsold inventory, offering mortgage rate buydowns as low as 4.5%, and the median price of a new home is actually $1,400 less than an existing home—a reversal of the normal premium. Dave Meyer of BiggerPockets ran a head-to-head comparison of two deals in the same market—Sherman, Texas—to see whether the classic BRRRR (Buy, Rehab, Rent, Refinance, Repeat) still beats new construction, or whether the market has shifted enough to make the lower-effort option the smarter play.

Why New Construction Deserves a Look Right Now

Four factors make new construction unusually attractive in 2026. First, builders have a fundamentally different business model than individual sellers. A homeowner who doesn't like the offers can simply stay put. A builder, by contrast, must move inventory—every month a finished home sits unsold is carrying costs with no revenue. That pressure translates into real concessions. Builders are advertising 5.5% mortgage rates on their websites, and Meyer believes a savvy investor can negotiate down to 4.5% through a rate buydown, plus get closing costs covered entirely.

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

Listen to Audio Summary Open in App

Never miss an episode of BiggerPockets Real Estate Podcast

Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

What you'll learn

1 (00:40) **The Core Question: BRRRR vs. New Construction in 2026** - Dave introduces the central debate: whether to buy a fixer-upper or a brand-new home for rental income, given the current market conditions.
2 (01:48) **Why New Construction is Worth Considering Now** - Dave explains the four key market factors that make new construction a viable strategy for the first time in his investing career.
3 (05:24) **The Analysis Setup: Sherman, Texas** - Dave explains his methodology for a fair comparison, selecting a specific market with strong fundamentals.
4 (10:44) **Running the Numbers: The New Construction Deal** - Dave walks through the initial analysis of the new construction property using the BiggerPockets calculator.
5 (18:03) **Negotiation Strategy for New Construction** - Dave outlines how to leverage a builder's business model to get the best deal.
6 (27:00) **Running the Numbers: The BRRRR Deal** - Dave analyzes the fixer-upper, estimating a $30,000-$35,000 renovation budget and an after-repair value (ARV) of $260,000-$270,000.
7 (33:54) **The Decisive Metric: Compound Annual Growth Rate** - Dave highlights the key difference: the BRRRR's ability to build equity far outpaces new construction.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Guests on this episode

Dave Meyer

Show Notes

Is it better to buy an existing property with value-add potential or a new construction home in 2026?

For years, there was no debate. The ability to buy a property at a discount, add value through renovations, force appreciation, and recycle your money made the BRRRR method a no-brainer for most investors.

But in 2026, things are a little different. Builders are sitting on inventory, which means new homes are being sold for less than we’ve seen in years. Not to mention, builders are giving buyers massive incentives like mortgage rate buydowns, closing credits, and even price reductions—just to get these properties off their books.

But are these perks enough to make new construction a better option than the BRRRR strategy?

Today, we’re going to put them head-to-head and find out. I’m comparing two real estate deals in the exact same market—a new construction home and a value-add property. We’ll crunch the numbers and see which strategy actually comes out on top from a cash flow and appreciation perspective. The answer may surprise you.

In This Episode We Cover

Three scenarios when you might prefer a new build to a fixer-upper

A head-to-head comparison of two real estate deals in the same market

How to negotiate huge builder incentives when buying a new home

How to choose the right investing strategy for you in 2026

The biggest pros and cons of buying a new construction home

And So Much More!

Check out more resources from this show on ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠