Bigfoot and Beyond with Cliff and Bobo
Bigfoot and Beyond with Cliff and Bobo

Ep. 392 - Bigfoot & Beyond a Reasonable Doubt!

November 9, 2026

AI Summary

5 min read

In a small college tucked into the Blue Ridge Mountains of North Carolina, a former detective is using Bigfoot to teach criminal justice students how jurors actually think. Derek Lale, program coordinator for criminal justice at Lees-McRae College, spent years building federal conspiracy cases with the FBI and Secret Service—cases that relied almost entirely on circumstantial evidence. When he pivoted to teaching, he realized his students were far more likely to serve as jurors than as cops or lawyers, and that no existing course prepared them for that role. So he built one around an unlikely test subject: the Sasquatch.

Why Bigfoot is a perfect teaching tool for juror bias

Lale's course tests juror preconceptions and decision-making by using Bigfoot evidence as the vehicle. Students study witness testimony, trace evidence, and the logic of building a circumstantial case—then their final project requires them to convince volunteer jurors that there is reasonable doubt about the claim that no bipedal, hairy creature exists in North American woods. They choose their own evidence, and they use Matt Moneymaker's book as their guide.

Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.

Read Full Summary →

Free • No credit card required

What you'll learn

  • 1 (02:18) **Introducing Derek Lale** - Cliff and Bobo welcome Derek, a former detective turned criminal justice professor who uses Bigfoot evidence in his courtroom simulation coursework.
  • 2 (05:49) **How the Bigfoot Course Works** - Derek outlines the structure of his pilot course, where students test juror preconceptions by presenting Bigfoot evidence to volunteer jurors.
  • 3 (08:41) **The Criminal Justice Lens on Sasquatch Evidence** - Derek explains why his law enforcement background makes him see Sasquatch research as a circumstantial evidence case, not a scientific one.
  • 4 (12:41) **Defining Circumstantial Evidence** - At Bobo's request, Derek clarifies what "circumstantial" means in legal terms and how it applies to physical Bigfoot evidence.
  • 5 (24:41) **Eyewitness Testimony: Faults and Value** - Derek describes a classroom simulation where a fake student slapped him to demonstrate how unreliable eyewitness memory is, even in the moment.
  • 6 (29:48) **Are Police Officers Trained Observers?** - Derek pushes back on the idea that cops are inherently more reliable witnesses, noting that basic training doesn't include observation blocks.
  • 7 (33:10) **Hearsay and Its Sasquatch Analogy** - Derek defines hearsay as testifying to something someone else said, which is exactly what researchers do when they relay a witness's story without the witness present.

+ Full timestamped outline available in the app

Show Notes

Cliff Barackman, James "Bobo" Fay, and Matt Pruitt speak with Derrick Lail, Program Coordinator of Criminal Justice at Lees-McRae College! Derrick discusses his years in law enforcement, his near-decade of teaching students about the justice system, the evaluation/presentation of circumstantial evidence, and how these experiences relate to sasquatchery! His interest in the sasquatch phenomenon has resulted the creation of a course offered at Lees-McRae called "The Bigfoot Effect: Evidence and Jury Preconceptions."

Check out Derrick and his son interviewing Dr. Jeff Meldrum!

See Cliff and Pruitt at the following events:

Cryptid Con in Florence, IN, November 21-22!

sQuatchFest, Kelso-Longview, WA, January 29-30

Oklahoma BigfootCon, Tahlequah, OK, April 8-10

Sign up for our weekly bonus podcast "Beyond Bigfoot & Beyond" and ad-free episodes!

Check out the Official "Bigfoot & Beyond" Merchandise Store!


Bigfoot and Beyond with Cliff and Bobo