Episode 393: Leaving the LDS Church | feat. Kighley Medrano
October 12, 2026
AI Summary
5 min readEpisode 393: Leaving the LDS Church | feat. Kighley Medrano
When Kighley Medrano's six-year-old daughter asked if the family could attend church with dad instead of mom one Sunday, Kighley agreed — she had always wanted her children to choose their faith freely, not feel forced into it like she had. That Sunday, the sermon at Harris Creek was about Kobe Bryant's death and the online debate over whether he was a Christian. Kighley left the auditorium feeling "like crap." She had no idea that within a week, everything she believed would unravel.
Growing Up Mormon in East Texas
Kighley was raised in the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints in Gilmer, East Texas — a pocket of the state with a significant LDS community. She grew up thinking everyone was Mormon. She didn't realize other Bibles were thinner until she saw one and asked, "Why are y'all's scriptures so skinny?" Her mother took the family to church every Sunday and to seminary classes in the mornings. The goal of Mormonism, Kighley explains, is to be "sealed in the temple to your family for time and all eternity" — a ritual that requires a temple recommend, which in turn requires obeying the "word of wisdom" (no tea, coffee, alcohol, or drugs) and passing worthiness interviews.
Continue reading the full summary in the app — free to try.
Read Full Summary →Free • No credit card required
Never miss an episode of Becoming Something with Jonathan Pokluda
Get every new episode summarized in your inbox — free, ~5 minutes to read.
No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
What you'll learn
- 1 (00:11) **Opening & Guest Introduction** - JP and Nate introduce guest Kighley Medrano, an ex-Mormon, with humorous banter about cults and Waco.
- 2 (03:54) **Growing Up Mormon in East Texas** - Kighley describes her normal-seeming childhood in a devout LDS family, unaware others weren't Mormon.
- 3 (07:12) **Marriage, Missionary Work, and Early Conflicts** - Kighley explains how she married a non-Mormon and the resulting theological arguments.
- 4 (10:20) **The Temple, Garments, and LDS Rituals Explained** - Kighley details the temple rituals, including the "new name," "endowments," and the "holy underwear."
- 5 (13:44) **The Seed of the Gospel** - Kighley recounts how her husband first shared the gospel of grace with her years before her conversion.
- 6 (15:05) **The Turning Point: A Sermon and a Playdate** - Kighley describes the two events that triggered her paradigm shift.
- 7 (19:50) **The Collapse: "The Church Isn't True"** - Kighley describes the emotional and spiritual crisis of realizing her entire worldview was a lie.
+ Full timestamped outline available in the app
Show Notes
This week we sit down with Kyleigh, who grew up devout Mormon in East Texas and spent years believing she had to earn her way to heaven and the moment everything changed for her and she gave her life to Christ. It was an eye-opening and insightful conversation that we think will be very helpful to you as you engage with people from the LDS church.
More from this podcast
Becoming Something with Jonathan Pokluda →