Coached to Kill

🎙️ The Voices & The Context

• The Format: This investigative true crime narrative weaves reenactments, dashcam footage analysis, and emotional interviews to unravel a rural Indiana murder, building relentless suspense through shocking revelations and courtroom drama.
• The Format: This is a narrative story featuring interviews with detectives, prosecutors, victims' family, witnesses, and suspects.
• The Key Players:
  • Wes Schemenauer: Elected prosecutor who led the trials, providing sharp legal insights into the unexpected arrests and convictions.
  • Ben Schwartz: Lead detective whose methodical interviews exposed the plot, delivering gritty scene recreations.
  • Tracy Havel & Family: Shay's heartbroken mother and relatives, sharing raw grief and suspicions that humanize the victim.
  • Christy Cybre: Key witness and former cop whose chilling confessions cracked the case wide open.
  • Pastor Angela Smiley: Shay's church mentor, offering poignant glimpses into his quest for fatherhood.